[Semifinal 4] WINNERS: Simple Love & Tornado

[jayx8318x]

SOO SORRY guys!! I've been busy and haven't been able to finish this up. I didn't have time to think of any new fun way to vote, so to be consistent with the last 3, we'll just do the same thing again.

If you don't understand what to do, look at the Semifinal 1,2,3 threads!!


The songs are:
A Herbalist Manual (Still Fantasy - Track 4)
Garden Festival (Common Jasmin Orange - Track 9)
Simple Love (Fantasy - Track 3)
Tornado (Jay Album - Track 9)
Black Sweater (November's Chopin - Track 4)


A Herbalist Manual - 100
Garden Festival - 100
Simple Love - 100
Tornado - 100
Black Sweater - 100


REMEMBER, YOU CAN ONLY VOTE AGAIN EVERY 10 POSTS!

[chinook]

Tornado + 10
Black Sweater - 10


A Herbalist Manual - 100
Garden Festival - 100
Simple Love - 100
Tornado - 110
Black Sweater - 90


Yay I'm first! :)

[sushii]

hehe more voting yay!!! eh..i like herbalist manual..but its not the best. so its gonna have to get -10..and i love simple love..so it gets the points!

Herbalist Manual-10
Simple Love+10

A Herbalist Manual - 90
Garden Festival - 100
Simple Love - 110
Tornado - 110
Black Sweater - 90

[Pao-Pao]

I love Tornado and Simple Love but this time I voted for Tornado cuz it rocks!!

Tornado +10
A Herbalist Manual -10

A Herbalist Manual - 80
Garden Festival - 100
Simple Love - 110
Tornado - 120
Black Sweater - 90

[junnleenfaah]

Simple Love +10
A Herbalist Manual -10

A Herbalist Manual - 70
Garden Festival - 100
Simple Love - 120
Tornado - 120
Black Sweater - 90

oh jeez.. this one is really hard to vote for =/ but jian dan ai is a classic, gotta go for that one

[Shu1Yah]

Simple Love +10
A Herbalist Manual -10

A Herbalist Manual - 60
Garden Festival - 100
Simple Love - 130
Tornado - 120
Black Sweater - 90


argg.... hard hard one ne!! hm..... i chose Simple Love because when i first listened to it, i got so hooked into it that i listened to it at least 30x in a row.. ^.^

[jay_is_cute]

Herbalist Manual: -10
Tornado: +10


A Herbalist Manual - 50
Garden Festival - 100
Simple Love - 130
Tornado - 130
Black Sweater - 90

it was easy to choose the one i didn't like, but i was stuck between tornado, simple love, and garden festival. in the end, i just love tornado the most.

[PinkDagger]

A Herbalist Manual: -10
Simple Love: +10

A Herbalist Manual - 40
Garden Festival - 100
Simple Love - 140
Tornado - 130
Black Sweater - 90

[seifer993]

Herbal Manual + 10
Blk Sweater-10

A Herbalist Manual - 50
Garden Festival - 100
Simple Love - 140
Tornado - 130
Black Sweater - 80

Herbal Manual is such a nice song,why is it losing?:cry:

[xanimeotakux]

i...hate...herbalist manual. i just hate it! the rap gets on my nerves, and the mv is horrible. >.< i can't stand it! and i love simple love. i have to vote for that one. <3

originally posted by xanimeotakux's vote

a herbalist manual -10
simple love +10

a herbalist manual - 40
garden festival - 100
simple love - 150
tornado - 130
black sweater - 80

[babysmurf]

Give it up for classic simple love & tornado!

black sweater -10
tornado +10

a herbalist manual - 40
garden festival - 100
simple love - 150
tornado - 140
black sweater - 70

[pepprmint]

omg Simple Love!! my #1 favorite song!! but i have to pitch it against tornado?! omgomg and the blood pressure starts to rise >.<
Originally Posted by pepprmint's vote
black sweater -10
simple love +10

a herbalist manual - 40
garden festival - 100
simple love - 160
tornado - 140
black sweater - 60

[cinnimon~]

this is tough, considering that i like every song here except garden festival. i dont know, i just dont like the song. and i HEART simple love :excited:


simple love- +10
garden festival- -10

a herbalist manual - 40
garden festival - 90
simple love - 170
tornado - 140
black sweater - 60

[newsletter]

Never really liked simple love

Garden festival +10
Simple love -10

a herbalist manual - 40
garden festival - 100
simple love - 160
tornado - 140
black sweater - 60

[iphei]

I've just got no love whatsoever for Garden Festival. The song was bad enough, but the video was much worse.

simple love - +10
garden festival - -10

a herbalist manual - 40
garden festival - 90
simple love - 180
tornado - 140
black sweater - 60

[sUm^MeR]

I just have to get rid of Herbalist Manual. That song is just annoying.

Herbalist Manual -10
Tornado +10



a herbalist manual - 30
garden festival - 90
simple love - 180
tornado - 150
black sweater - 60

[mjay]

There's a bit of mistake with simple love's points right, i'll just correct it.
Tornado and simple love has got to be 2 of my fav jay songs!
My vote goes to-
Simple Love +10
Garden festival -10
a herbalist manual - 30
garden festival - 80
simple love - 180
tornado - 150
black sweater - 60

[pamujung]

Garden Festival +10 pts
Black Sweater -10 pts

A Herbalist Manual - 30
Garden Festival - 90
Simple Love - 180
Tornado - 150
Black Sweater - 50
I like Garden Festival more !

and why can't people make it's more tidy, color please.

[*meow]

Herbalist's Manual -10
Garden Festival +10

A Herbalist Manual - 20
Garden Festival - 100
Simple Love - 180
Tornado - 150
Black Sweater - 50

Pam, same here! i love Garden Fest too. :D & i love it to bits.
sorry, Ben Cao Gang Mu. as much as i love you, i have to take 10 points off. :sweat:

[jay4ever]

Black Sweater -10
Garden Festival +10


A Herbalist Manual - 20
Garden Festival - 110
Simple Love - 180
Tornado - 150
Black Sweater - 40


me too... just love garden festival among these few songs....

[jay_fantasy8]

A Herbalist Manual -10
Simple Love +10

A Herbalist Manual - 10
Garden Festival - 110
Simple Love - 190
Tornado - 150
Black Sweater - 40

i totally adore simple love . i like the catchy rhythm and the 'happy' feel in this song . the sweet mv is really nice to watch too, and just makes everything so lovely to look and listen at .

[Pao-Pao]

My second vote hehe...I love love Tornado so this vote is for Tornado too!!!

A Herbalist Manual -10
Tornado +10

A Herbalist Manual - 0
Garden Festival - 110
Simple Love - 190
Tornado - 160
Black Sweater - 40

[nightshade]

I love, love, love Simple Love. It's so sweet and innocent and kind of perfect.

Originally Posted by nightshade's vote

Simple Love +10
Black Sweater -10

Garden Festival - 110
Simple Love - 200
Tornado - 160
Black Sweater - 30

[babysmurf]

Tornado is the official song that makes me really in love with Jay.
It's a masterpiece!

Tornado +10
Black Sweater -10

Garden Festival - 110
Simple Love - 200
Tornado - 170
Black Sweater - 20

[lovingjay]

Tornado truly was the first song that I heard by Jay. And it's a CLASSIC! Black sweater was just too bland for me..the mv and the song.
Tornado +10
Black Sweater -10

Garden Festival - 110
Simple Love - 200
Tornado - 180
Black Sweater - 10

[ShuiMei]

Simple Love +10
Black Sweater -10

Garden Festival - 110
Simple Love - 210
Tornado - 180
Black Sweater - 0
Simple Love is one of my favourite songs, to not vote for it would be a crime XD and yay, I get to kill off Black Sweater! It's an okay song but definitely not one of Jay's best, and the little droplet sounds always piss me off, sounds too commercial.

[lanny]

Tornado +10
Garden Festival -10

Garden Festival - 100
Simple Love - 200
Tornado - 180

oh damn...that was quick..i was off by a min with ShuiMei..n yea..she eliminated my Black Sweater..i was bouts to save it too..oh wellz...heres the edited one...

[junnleenfaah]

Simple Love +10
Tornado -10

Garden Festival - 100
Simple Love - 210
Tornado - 170

oh gosh.. this is getting hard now cuz i LOVE all these songs =/ meh. voting sucks now, hahaha

[pepprmint]

pheww thank goodness my favorite song is still safe and sound at the top, less to worry about :happy: not sure which one i love less, buuut, gotta go with tornado >.< siiiigh...
Simple Love +10
tornado -10

Garden Festival - 100
Simple Love - 220
Tornado - 160

[HarmonyCloud]

Garden Festival - +10
Tornado - 10

Garden Festival - 110
Simple Love - 220
Tornado - 150




Sorry If I quoted this wrong but I think I did it right :oops:

[xiaojielun]

hurmmmm i think my vote will be the same as pepprmint :-)



Garden Festival +10
Tornado - 10

Garden Festival - 120
Simple Love - 220
Tornado - 140

[sUm^MeR]

I'm here to save my all-time favorite song!

Tornado +10
Garden Festival -10


Garden Festival - 110
Simple Love - 220
Tornado - 150

[xanimeotakux]

gah, this is so hard! but out of these 3, i think garden festival has to go. =/

originally posted by xanimeotakux's vote

simple love +10
Garden Festival -10

Garden Festival - 100
Simple Love - 230
Tornado - 150

[ankh]

I love all 3 songs but still prefer Tornado over Garden Festival!

Tornado +10
Garden Festival -10

Garden Festival - 90
Simple Love - 230
Tornado - 160

[mjay]

me too, i prefer tornado over garden festival

Tornado +10
Garden Festival -10

Garden Festival - 80
Simple Love - 230
Tornado - 170

[babysmurf]

Woghh, down to 3 already, this group seems easy.

Tornado +10
Garden Festival -10

Quote:
Garden Festival - 70
Simple Love - 230
Tornado - 180

[pinkfireworks]

It's hard to decide between A Simple Love and Garden Festival. =(((

Tornado - 10
Garden Festival + 10

Garden Festival - 80
Simple Love - 230
Tornado - 170

[seifer993]

Garden Festival +10
Tornado - 10

Garden Festival - 90
Simple Love - 230
Tornado - 160

So difficult to choose.i think i will save garden festival.

[pepprmint]

sighh, im back to betray tornado again, siiigh, votings getting so tough now >.<
Simple Love +10
Tornado - 10

Garden Festival - 90
Simple Love - 240
Tornado - 150

[ShuiMei]

Tornado + 10
Garden Festival - 10

Garden Festival - 80
Simple Love - 240
Tornado - 160

I like all of these songs, including Garden Festival, but it's no Tornado...

[pamujung]

Tornado -10 pts
Garden Festival +10 pts

Garden Festival - 90
Simple Love - 240
Tornado - 150
I like the song that most of us hate *gigles*

[judes]

oh my god GARDEN FESTIVAL.
i hate tornado. it's so overplayed.

Tornado -10 pts
Garden Festival +10 pts

Garden Festival - 100
Simple Love - 240
Tornado - 140

[jaychou_21]

I love Jian Dan Ai soo much. :love:

I like this batch a lot but unfortunately for Garden Festival, it's my least favorite among the three so it gets my boot.


Simple Love +10
Garden Festival -10

Garden Festival - 90
Simple Love - 250
Tornado - 140

[Shu1Yah]

lol. Pam sensei~ me love Garden Fest too ne~ although Simple Love and Tornado is tugging at me :oops: hmm...


Simple Love - 10
Garden Festival +10

Garden Festival - 100
Simple Love - 240
Tornado - 140

[sUm^MeR]

From the three songs left, I actually don't like Simple Love all that much. But people seem to be so fond of it. :worry: So I don't think reducing 10 points from Simple Love would make any difference, because people would keep on adding the points back. So... I think I must at least put Tornado as one of the winners.

Anyway... here's my vote.

Tornado +10
Garden Festival -10


Garden Festival - 90
Simple Love - 240
Tornado - 150

[happifruit]

I don't care that Simple Love will get points added back. I'm still taking points away.

Simple Love -10
Tornado +10


Garden Festival - 90
Simple Love - 230
Tornado - 160

[babysmurf]

I'm gonna keep voting for tornado till the end!!

Garden Festival -10
Tornado +10

Garden Festival - 80
Simple Love - 230
Tornado - 170

[pinkfireworks]

Go go Garden Festival! =D And sorry Tornado~

Garden Festival +10
Tornado - 10

Garden Festival - 90
Simple Love - 230
Tornado - 160

[seifer993]

GardenFestival + 10
Tornado - 10

Garden Festival - 100
Simple Love - 230
Tornado - 150
dont really like tornado.find it quite boring after a while.garden festival rocks.:-)

[xanimeotakux]

aw...i adore simple love so much! that's the only song i memorized out of jay's millions of songs! XD (i know, i suck. =.=)

originally posted by xanimeotakux's vote
garden festival -10
simple love +10

garden festival- 90
simple love- 240
tornado- 150

[pepprmint]

o wow, simple love is the only jay song i completely memorized too! probably cuz its so simple..(bad pun, ok -_-") goo jian dan aiii!
originally posted by pepprmint's vote
tornado -10
simple love +10

garden festival- 90
simple love- 250
tornado- 140

[¦-Metal-Gear-¦]

okay. here's my vote.
yeah. simple love all the way!! lols.

originally posted by ¦-Metal-Gear-¦'s vote
tornado -10
simple love +10

garden festival- 90
simple love- 260
tornado- 130

[lanny]

tornado +10
garden festival -10

garden festival- 80
simple love- 260
tornado- 140

Tornadooooo...Lannn to the rescue!!! have to keep it, man!

[jay_is_cute]

garden festival: -10
tornado: +10


garden festival- 70
simple love- 260
tornado- 150

Not that I don't love garden festival, but I just can't take away from the other two, all-time classics.

[sUm^MeR]

:glug:
Simple Love has reached over 200?!!!

Seriously, I don't understand why people keep deducting points from Tornado. :cry: That's probably my all-time fave song from Jay.

Tornado +10
Garden Festival -10


garden festival- 60
simple love- 260
tornado- 160

[chinook]

Tornado +10
Simple Love -10


garden festival- 60
simple love- 250
tornado- 170


yeah! tornado is one of Jay's earliest compositions and I still think it's very good! gonna have to deduct from simple love this time..

[ker_ai_teresa]

come on!! Garden Festival is the bestest!
makes me wanna get up and start balleting across my room when it comes on! :rolleyes:


Garden Festival +10
Simple Love -10

garden festival- 70
simple love- 240
tornado- 170

[tc9.jay]

Tornado is pure classic! Garden Festival would have to go.. Sorry..

Tornado +10
Garden Festival -10

garden festival- 60
simple love- 240
tornado- 180

[babysmurf]

YES! YES! YES! Tornado indeed is the best.

Tornado +10
Garden Festival -10

garden festival- 50
simple love- 240
tornado- 190

[hk-kc-jc]

Garden Festival +10
Tornado -10

Garden Festival - 60
Simple Love - 240
Tornado - 180

come on GARDEN FESTIVAL!! MUST CATCH UP!!

[mjay]

Sorry, garden festival...

Tornado +10
Garden Festival -10

Garden Festival - 50
Simple Love - 240
Tornado - 190

[xanimeotakux]

sorry garden festival...out of these 3, i'll have to subtract from this song.. >.<

originally posted by xanimeotakux's vote

simple love +10
garden festival -10

garden festival - 40
simple love - 250
tornado - 190

[melody90]

simple love +10
garden festival -10

garden festival - 30
simple love - 260
tornado - 190

Simple Love is definitely my favourite jay song here..

[junnleenfaah]

simple love +10
tornado -10

garden festival - 30
simple love - 270
tornado - 180

eesh, tough luck for garden festival =/ but i like it more than tornado (:

[sushii]

yeah yeah simple love simple love and tornado ^^

simple love +10
garden festival -10

garden festival - 20
simple love - 280
tornado - 180

[happifruit]

Taking points away from Simple Love now won't make a difference, so I am keeping it around in hopes of knocking it out in the future.


Garden Festival -10
Tornado +10

garden festival - 10
simple love - 280
tornado - 190

[v3rmillion]

simple love -10
Tornado +10

garden festival - 10
simple love - 270
tornado - 200


I don;t really like or dislike Garden Festival, but I've listened to Simple love waaaaay to many times

[pepprmint]

o gawwd, tornado or garden festival =/ since i cant bear being the one to oust it, i think i'll just take off from tornado..
simple love +10
Tornado -10

garden festival - 10
simple love - 280
tornado - 190

[nightshade]

Ooh! I get to strike the deathblow! I feel like I'm experiencing a historic moment. Go Simple Love!

simple love +10
Tornado -10

garden festival - 0
simple love - 290
tornado - 190