[Semifinal 3] WINNERS: Dad I'm Back & Nocturne

[jayx8318x]

If you don't know how to play, please refer to the other Semifinal threads in this forum. Particularly the 1st one (http://www.jay-chou.net/forums/showthread.php?t=24934) where all the rules are.

The songs are:

Dad I Came Back (Ba Wo Hui Lai Le) - (Fantasy - Track 2)
Nocturne (November's Chopin - Track 1)
Golden Armor (Curse of the Golden Flower - Track 1)
Beseiged from All Sides (November's Chopin - Track 5)
My Territory - (Common Jasmin Orange - Track 1)

I won't vote yet since I need to think about this one.
I can't reiterate enough, please vote truthfully! I hated seeing in the first thread "Well I like song X, but it's pointless to vote for it now since it's losing" =(




Dad I Came Back - 100
Nocturne - 100
Golden Armor - 100
Beseiged from All Sides - 100
My Territory - 100

[ankh]

So can I start the ball rolling?

Also had a hard time on this one since I like both Dad I'm back and Nocturne.
No one song I hate over here so this one's completely up to which one I like more and less.

Originally Posted by ankh's vote
Dad I Came Back +10
My Territory - 10

Dad I Came Back - 110
Nocturne - 100
Golden Armor - 100
Beseiged from All Sides - 100
My Territory - 90

[nightshade]

Oh! I like all the songs except for "My Territory." This is hard.

Originally Posted by nightshade's vote
Besieged from All Sides+10
My Territory - 10

Dad I Came Back - 110
Nocturne - 100
Golden Armor - 100
Besieged from All Sides - 110
My Territory - 80

[Pao-Pao]

Ok Nocturne has to win!! :happy: but My terrytory is a really good song also so I'll back to vote again tomorrow haha lol

Originally Posted by Pao-Pao's vote
Nocturne +10
Golden Armor - 10

Dad I Came Back - 110
Nocturne - 110
Golden Armor - 90
Beseiged from All Sides - 110
My Territory - 80

[Shu1Yah]

Hmm.... this is a tough vote ne, I mostly don't like all of these songs but I chose My Territory. Pumps me up when I'm doing hmwk :D


My Territory +10
Beseiged from All Sides - 10

Dad I Came Back - 110
Nocturne - 110
Golden Armor - 90
Beseiged from All Sides - 100
My Territory - 90

[hk-kc-jc]

These are all really good songs.. :hmm: think...think...think...

Beseiged from all Sides + 10
Dad I Came Back -10

Dad I Came Back - 100
Nocturne - 110
Golden Armor - 90
Beseiged from all sides - 110
My Territory - 90

[pepprmint]

ahh i lOve nocturne!! atleast this one isnt as hard as the semifinal2 one, that one was a headache >.<

Originally Posted by pepprmint's vote
Nocturne +10
My Territory - 10

Dad I Came Back - 110
Nocturne - 120
Golden Armor - 90
Beseiged from All Sides - 100
My Territory - 80

[joeymcjojo]

My Territory's great! Beseiged annoys me.

Originally Posted by joeymcjojo's vote
My Territory+10
Beseiged from All Sides- 10

Dad I Came Back - 110
Nocturne - 120
Golden Armor - 90
Beseiged from All Sides - 90
My Territory - 90

[junnleenfaah]

Originally Posted by junnleenfaah's vote
My Territory+10
Beseiged from All Sides- 10

Dad I Came Back - 110
Nocturne - 120
Golden Armor - 90
Beseiged from All Sides - 80
My Territory - 100

i completely agree with the same votes as joey =P besieged.. ew-yuck.

[browneyes]

November Chopin album all the way
Nocturne +10
Dad I Came Back -10


Dad I Came Back - 100
Nocturne - 130
Golden Armor - 90
Beseiged from All Sides - 80
My Territory - 100

[sushii]

oh man..this was really hard to choose..i really like all the songs..

Golden Armour-10
Nocturne +10

Dad come Back- 100
Nocturne-140
Golden Armour- 80
Beseiged from all Sides- 80
My Territory-100

[judes]

Golden Armour-10
Dad I'm Back +10

Dad I'm Back- 110
Nocturne-140
Golden Armour- 70
Beseiged from all Sides- 80
My Territory-100

[babysmurf]

I don't think gorden armour is good enough to reach final, must eliminate it!

Golden Armour-10
Nocturne +10

Dad I'm Back 110
Nocturne 150
Golden Armour 60
Beseiged from all Sides 80
My Territory 100

[yenny1106]

Didn't like Huang Jin Jia, nothing very impactful.. My Territory;'s cute! haha..


Golden Armour-10
My Territory +10

Dad I'm Back 110
Nocturne 150
Golden Armour 50
Beseiged from all Sides 80
My Territory 110

[newsletter]

Go nocturne!
<3 Nocturne +10
Golden Armor -10

Dad I'm Back 110
Nocturne 160
Golden Armour 40
Beseiged from all Sides 80
My Territory 100

[yenny1106]

hey newsletter@! hee.. u did not add 10 for my territory..

[v3rmillion]

ahh this is hard for me..I like pretty much all the songs in this round

Originally Posted by v3rmillion
Dad I Came Back +10
My Territory -10

Dad I'm Back 120
Nocturne 160
Golden Armour 40
Beseiged from all Sides 80
My Territory 100

my territory is 100 based on yenny1106's post

[jay_fantasy8]

Originally Posted by jay_fantasy8's vote
Dad I Came Back +10
My Territory -10

Dad I'm Back 130
Nocturne 160
Golden Armour 40
Beseiged from all Sides 80
My Territory 90
ahh . i can make a clear decision in this one cause i detest my territory and super love dad i'm back . x)

[xanimeotakux]

oh gosh, i hope golden armor wins! :cry:

Originally Posted by xanimeotakux's vote

golden armor +10
My Territory -10

Dad I'm Back 130
Nocturne 160
Golden Armour 50
Beseiged from all Sides 80
My Territory 70

[pamujung]

Nocturne +10 pts
Beseiged from all Sides -10 pts

Dad I'm Back 130
Nocturne 170
Golden Armour 50
Beseiged from all Sides 70
My Territory 70

; I guess it's much easier if we didn't have to quote :happy:

[aina]

+10 pts for Nocturne
- 10 pts for....gosh this is hard....Golden Armour...

Dad I'm Back 130
Nocturne 180
Golden Armour 40
Beseiged from all Sides 70
My Territory 70

[Erishii]

+10 Nocturne (LOVELOVELOVE!!!)
-10 My Territory (this song annoys me...)


Dad I'm Back 130
Nocturne 190
Golden Armour 40
Beseiged from all Sides 70
My Territory 60

[jayx8318x]

I'm sure I like Dad I'm Back at some point, but in comparison to these songs, it ranks lowest for me. I didn't like Beseiged at first, but the video is awesome! So in a way it made me like the song more.

Dad I'm Back - 10
Beseiged + 10

Dad I'm Back 120
Nocturne 190
Golden Armour 40
Beseiged from all Sides 80
My Territory 60

[jay_is_cute]

Nocturne: +10 (listened to this non-stop when it first came out)
My Territory: -10 (don't hate it, but it's the least favorite)


Dad I'm Back 120
Nocturne 200
Golden Armour 40
Beseiged from all Sides 80
My Territory 50

[¦-Metal-Gear-¦]

dad i'm back is my fav song!

Dad I'm Back +10
My Territory -10
Dad I'm Back 130
Nocturne 200
Golden Armour 40
Beseiged from all Sides 80
My Territory 40

[junnleenfaah]

Dad I'm Back 130
Nocturne 200
Golden Armour 40
Beseiged from all Sides 70
My Territory 50

must.. keep.. my territory.. in! still ew-yuck for beseiged =P

[lanny]

Nocturne +10
My Territory -10


Dad I'm Back 130
Nocturne 210
Golden Armour 40
Beseiged from all Sides 70
My Territory 40

damnn..finding the one that i dislike is easy...but the one that i like...?? thats soo0o0o0o0 hard...i love them all....gahh...i guess i ended up choosing nocturne just cuz its a very sad song..n its my bf's ringtone on my phone....n yea..just love that song...

[pepprmint]

here i go again, just to set nocturne's place in stone, might as well oust golden armor while im at it, probably cuz its a new song, still havent quite warmed up to it yet...
Dad I'm Back 130
Nocturne 220
Golden Armour 30
Beseiged from all Sides 70
My Territory 40

[babysmurf]

I dislike golden armour, even the MV is weird, jay in a purple bird outfit...:wacko:

Nocturne +10
Golden Armour -10


Dad I'm Back 130
Nocturne 230
Golden Armour 20
Beseiged from all Sides 70
My Territory 40

[xanimeotakux]

ahh! i can't let golden armor disappear! >.<

golden armor +10
my territory -10

dad i'm back 130
nocture 230
golden armor 30
beseiged from all sides 70
my territory 30

[icetears-]

Orginally posted by icetears-'s vote

beseiged from all sides +10
my territory -10

dad i'm back 130
nocturne 230
golden armor 30
beseiged from all sides 80
my territory 20

Sheesh I liked my territory, but then I loved the rest more :X

[joeymcjojo]

I'm not giving up on My Territory!!! It may be a lost cause, but it's a great song.

Orginally posted by joeymcjojo's 2nd vote

my territory +10
beseiged from all sides -10


dad i'm back 130
nocturne 230
golden armor 30
beseiged from all sides 70
my territory 30

[Iceblade24]

nocturne +10
beseiged from all sides -10


dad i'm back 130
nocturne 240
golden armor 30
beseiged from all sides 60
my territory 30

I really like dad i'm back, but.. nocturne is such a perfect song.

[qinshihuang]

imo, "dad i'm back" is one of jay's five best songs... and "beseiged from all sides" one of his five worst. i'm prolly gonna be beseiged from all sides for saying that.

dad i'm back +10
beseiged from all sides -10

dad i'm back 140
nocturne 240
golden armor 30
beseiged from all sides 50
my territory 30

[xiaojielun]

hurmmm at least this is easier than semifinal 2 i think hahaha
guess i'll try n get golden armour out of this haha



nocturne +10
golden armour -10

dad i'm back 140
nocturne 250
golden armor 20
beseiged from all sides 50
my territory 30

[cookielmy]

My first time voting, giving my first try.. Here it goes;

Originally Posted by cookielmy's vote

Golden Armor -10
Nocturne +10

Dad I'm Back 140
Nocturne 260
Golden Armor 10
Beseiged From All Sides 50
My Territory 30

[ziai]

Aww man I like all. But I guess I like My Territory the least among all the rest.


Originally Posted by ziai's vote

My Territory -10
Dad I'm back +10

Dad I'm Back 150
Nocturne 260
Golden Armor 10
Beseiged From All Sides 50
My Territory 20

[¦-Metal-Gear-¦]

okie Golden Armor is OUT!!
look like My Territory will be the 2nd one voted out.

hmm. still vote for my fav song in Fantasy!
=D
Originally Posted by ¦-Metal-Gear-¦'s 2nd vote

Golden Armor -10
Dad I'm back +10

Dad I'm Back 160
Nocturne 260
Golden Armor 0
Beseiged From All Sides 50
My Territory 20

[pamujung]

Beseiged From All Sides -10 pts
Nocturne +10 pts

Dad I'm Back 160
Nocturne 270
Golden Armor 0 (eliminated)
Beseiged From All Sides 40
My Territory 20
^^ Nocturne all the way! and I still think that WDDP is better than SMCG

[ShuiMei]

My Territory +10
Beseiged From All Sides-10

Dad I'm Back 160
Nocturne 270
Beseiged From All Sides 30
My Territory 30

I like all the songs, but I'm going to try to salvage My Territory for a bit longer, it has a certain charm xD

[drenickant]

Nocturne +10
Dad I'm Back -10

Dad I'm Back 150
Nocturne 280
Beseiged From All Sides 30
My Territory 30

I have to go with Nocturne for the +10 points, and Dad I'm Back for a -10...

[yenny1106]

i;m trying to salvage my territory! haha..

Originally Posted by yenny1106
My Territory +10
Beseiged From All Sides -10

Dad I'm Back 150
Nocturne 280
Beseiged From All Sides 20
My Territory 40

[gifted1]

My Territory +10
Beseiged From All Sides -10

Dad I'm Back - 150
Nocturne - 280
Beseiged From All Sides - 10
My Territory - 50


YEAH! My Territory! Let's continue voting!

[ShuiMei]

i just love Noturne.i actually kinda like beseiged all all side.but among all this song,beseiged from all side is my least favourite
Um, you actually took 10 from My Territory and not Beseiged From All Sides, so if you meant to take 10 away from Beseiged from All Sides, then shouldn't the numbers for your post be:

Dad I'm Back - 150
Nocturne - 290
Beseiged From All Sides - 0?
My Territory - 50

which would have technically eliminated Beseiged From All Sides?

[jayx8318x]

That's what she said. Alot of these voters confuse me too, they say one thing in their post, but their vote block is something totally different. Either way, we're going with what she said in the vote block.

edit: I'm just going to delete all votes from hers onwards, it'll get too messy to fix.
PLEASE CHECK YOUR VOTES BEFORE SUBMITTING!!


Does this mean that Nocturne is automatically through to the next round?
Not exactly, Nocturne can still be minus'ed

[pepprmint]

well, might as well push this through, yaaay for Nocturne! love that song ^_^
Originally Posted by pepprmint
Nocturne +10
My Territory -10

Dad I'm Back - 150
Beseiged From All Sides - 10
Nocturne - 300
My Territory - 40

[junnleenfaah]

Originally Posted by junnleenfaah

My Territory +10
Beseiged From All Sides -10

Dad I'm Back - 150
Beseiged From All Sides - 0 [eliminated]
Nocturne - 300
My Territory - 50

AAHHH MUST KEEP MY TERRITORY IN! bwahaha, i got beseiged out (: just the way i like it (:

btw, since nocturne hit the 300 cap, it automatically means it's one of the top two that will be a finalist for this round, correct?

[sushii]

voting again!!^ does that mean we can't vote on nocturne anymore? voting for dad i'm back cuase i love that song

dad, i'm back +10
my territory -10

dad i'm back-160
nocturne-300
my territory-40

[jayx8318x]

btw, since nocturne hit the 300 cap, it automatically means it's one of the top two that will be a finalist for this round, correct?

You can't ADD to Nocturne anymore, but people can still MINUS it. It does not mean automatic finalist. For example, if 30 people minus'ed it in a row, it will be eliminated.
People can throw away their PLUS vote since a song has hit the cap, and just minus a song.

[maddywolf]

My Territory +10
Dad I'm Back -10


Dad I'm Back - 150
nocturne-300
My Territory - 50
i was attracted to my territory upon 1st time hearing it

[Shu1Yah]

whee......... i shall vote again. Aww.. no one likes My Territory? I thought it sound good pretty good ne~


My Territory +10
Dad I'm Back -10

Dad I'm Back - 140
nocturne-300
My Territory - 60

[*meow]

Dad I'm back +10
Nocturne -10

Dad I'm Back -150
Nocturne- 290
My Territory- 60

no special feelings towards My Territory... but i really like Dad I'm back a lot! :D as for Nocturne, i minused points off it because i just don't like the way how people's impression of jay stops at his songs which get more airplay. :oops:

[shuren]

Originally Posted by shuren's vote
Dad I'm back +10
Nocturne -10
Dad I'm Back -160
Nocturne- 280
My Territory- 60
I like My territory but I still prefere Dad I'm back!!^^ GO GO GO Daddy!^^;

[xanimeotakux]

darn, why are people subtracting from nocturne? and golden armor is gone.. -__-

originally posted by xanimeotakux's vote

my territory -10
nocturne +10

dad i'm back 160
nocturne 290
my territory 50

[sushii]

ahh..no nocturne is one of my fav songs!!

nocturne +10
my territory -10

dad i'm back -160
nocturne-300
my territory -40

[joeymcjojo]

Nothing against Nocturne, but it's my least favorite out of the three, and since I've learned that I can subtract points from it, I'm gonna go crazy!!! I'm also just glad that Beseiged is gone, it makes me want to rip my arm off just so I have something to throw at it.

Originally posted by joeymcjojo's 4th vote
nocturne -10
my territory +10

dad i'm back -160
nocturne-290
my territory -50

[ShuiMei]

Nocturne -10
My Territory +10

Dad I'm Back - 160
Nocturne - 280
My Territory - 60

Same here, of the three Nocturne is my least favourite. Ideally I like Dad I'm Back and My Territory as the final two

[lanny]

Nocturne +10
My Territory -10

Dad I'm Back - 160
Nocturne - 290
My Territory - 50


have..to..keep...NOCTURNE!! its my favorite jay song that ive fell in love with first sight..or first listened to...

[Pao-Pao]

Ok guys I'm next...My territory is a really good song...at least I like it so I wanna give 10 points to My Territory...this is my favorite song after Nocturne.

Originally Posted by Pao-Pao's 2nd Vote
My Territory +10
Dad I'm back -10

Dad I'm Back - 150
Nocturne - 290
My Territory - 60

[sushii]

gaahhh...nocture must win!!!! It has to stay at the top!!!


my territory-10
nocturne +10

dad i'm back-150
nocturne-300
my territory-50

[icetears-]

Originally posted by icetears-'s 2nd vote
dad I'm back +10
my territory -10

dad i'm back - 160
nocturne - 300
my territory - 40


Dad I'm Back has lyrics that are so real, no way can it be eliminated. As for My Territory, it just doesn't go on my "best songs" list :wink2:

[babysmurf]

Dad i'm back music & lyrics makes me depressed. I prefer listening to My Territory.


dad I'm back -10
my territory +10

dad i'm back - 150
nocturne - 300
my territory - 50

[seifer993]

Myterritory+10
Dadimback-10

dad i'm back - 140
nocturne - 300
my territory - 60

My territory rocks.have to save it.:-)

[junnleenfaah]

Originally Posted by junnleenfaah's vote
My Territory +10
Nocturne - 10

dad i'm back - 140
nocturne - 290
my territory - 70

sorry for being anal, but i like keeping the neat format we had earlier when posting =/ anyway, nocturne.. don't like so much. glad to see my territory is still hanging in there (: btw, thanks karen for clearing things up for me (:

[v3rmillion]

Posted by v3rmillion's 2nd vote
Dad I'm back +10
My territory - 10

dad i'm back - 150
nocturne - 290
my territory - 60

'Dad I'm back' was one of my first Jay songs, and the lyrics are unique

[yenny1106]

Posted by yenny1106's 3rd vote
nocturne -10
My territory + 10

dad i'm back - 150
nocturne - 280
my territory - 70

I got bored listening to nocturn too many times.. but my territory's cool with the juan3 she1s. haha

[pamujung]

My Territory -10 pts
Dad I'm Back + 10 pts

Dad I'm Back - 160
Nocturne - 280
My Territory - 60
sorry WDDP >< but Dad I'm Back is my favorite

[nightshade]

Oh, my dislike for My Territory is so intense. I'm sad that Besieged is gone....

Originally Posted by nightshade's vote
My Territory -10 pts
Nocturne+ 10 pts

Dad I'm Back - 160
Nocturne - 290
My Territory - 50

[qinshihuang]

i guess i'll give a helping hand in eliminating my territory and preserving dad i'm back

Originally Posted by qinshihuang's vote
Dad I'm Back+10 pts
My Territory - 10 pts

Dad I'm Back - 170
Nocturne - 290
My Territory - 40

[joeymcjojo]

I'm voting often, but it's to save My Territory, I don't think I can let Nocturne win anymore.

Originally Posted by joeymcjojo's 5th vote
Nocturne - 10 pts
My Territory + 10 pts

Dad I'm Back - 170
Nocturne - 280
My Territory - 50

[¦-Metal-Gear-¦]

look like My Territory will be eliminated soon.
Dad I'm Back all the way! lols. =D

Originally Posted by ¦-Metal-Gear-¦'s vote
Dad I'm Back+10 pts
My Territory - 10 pts

Dad I'm Back - 180
Nocturne - 280
My Territory - 40

[pinkfireworks]

I was all ready to vote for Beseiged from All Sides and now I find it's gone. =(

Nocturne + 10
My Territory - 10

Dad I'm Back - 180
Nocturne - 290
My Territory - 30

[icetears-]

pinkfireworks; Yeah I wanted to vote for it previously too! Along with gold armour :cry:

Originally Posted by icetears-'s 3rd vote
Dad I'm Back + 10
My Territory - 10

Dad I'm Back - 190
Nocturne - 290
My Territory - 20

So there, DAD I'M BACK MUST REMAIN! :-)

[ker_ai_teresa]

Dad I'm Back +10
My Territory -10

Dad I'm Back - 200
Nocturne - 290
My Territory - 10

it was tough. Dad I'm Back or Nocturne?

Dad I'm Back. :-)

[ziai]

Say bye to My Territory :wave:


Originally Posted by ziai's 2nd vote
Dad I'm Back +10
My Territory -10

Dad I'm Back - 210
Nocturne - 290
My Territory - 0


YAY! Daddy!

[yenny1106]

Originally Posted by yenny1106's 4th vote
Dad I'm Back +10
Nocturne -10

Dad I'm Back - 220
Nocturne - 280

hmm since My Territory's gone, shall vote for Dad... love the haunting cello!

[petricia]

My two favourites....
What a struggle... but... Vincent Fong wins... haha.. Nocturne

Dad I'm Back -10
Nocturne +10
Dad I'm Back - 210
Nocturne - 290

[jayx8318x]

Why are you guys still voting? LOL
we eliminate 3 songs, so it's down to 2. This voting session is done. Thanks for participating!

Just 3 more semifinal voting threads, I have to think of a new way to vote though, stay tuned.