Has anyone caught any other mistakes Jay made in The One VCD

[NikeSwooshIn]

i can tell he made a mistake in half monster human and tried to cover it up he repets on part of the thing twice in the very beginning. then in shanghi he kinda mumbles to cover stuff up. has anyone discovered anything else? it is fun watching him make his mistakes its cute.\ :love:

[Jo]

its discussed partially here (http://www.jay-chou.net/forums/viewtopic.php?t=885)...for reference


listen to his songs on The One Concert...there are a lot of songs in which he messes up the lyrics...such as in Kai Bu Liao Ko (Can't Say) and the most obvious one...Shanghei 1943...he totally screwed up the order and the lyrics in that song

and if you watch his Concert MV...he gets pretty embarassed when he messes up and covers his face...its so funny ^ ^

yep i caught a lot of them...but at least he covers it up pretty well...unlike some other artists that just crack up on stage

-Jo

[NikeSwooshIn]

its discussed partially here (http://www.jay-chou.net/forums/viewtopic.php?t=885)...for reference


listen to his songs on The One Concert...there are a lot of songs in which he messes up the lyrics...such as in Kai Bu Liao Ko (Can't Say) and the most obvious one...Shanghei 1943...he totally screwed up the order and the lyrics in that song

and if you watch his Concert MV...he gets pretty embarassed when he messes up and covers his face...its so funny ^ ^

yep i caught a lot of them...but at least he covers it up pretty well...unlike some other artists that just crack up on stage

-Jo



whats the concert mv? i never heard of it.. where can you buy it?

[vivien17]

I think you guys are talking about the taiwan The One concert? I bought the cd and yeah its really funny how he makes allll these mistakes, but i must say he's really quick at improvising. Like he actually sings a phrase from the wrong part of the chorus and then realizes, and switches in the middle of it to the correct part! U can hardly tell cos he does it perfectly, like no misses in the rhythm at all, unless u're super familiar with the lyrics or just reading off the cd sleeve like me. I think its really adorable :p I wish i can watch the vcd and see his reaction when he sings the wrong thing.. Another song he messes up besides Kai Bu Liao Kou and Shanghai 1943 is Jolin's song, Why can't you even speak clearly..

[m o n k e e]

wen i 1st saw Shanghai 1943, i was like "oh no, he forgot the lyrics!" n i thought he was gona screw it up
but he covered it pretti well!

[xoxo]

that is just so cute, haha...so he is human after all!

[Ziwei]

oh.... i really nv notice eh... he's really so perfect in covering up!

[kewlpiggy88]

i can't really tell even if ppl say he does..i dunno if it's cuz my chinese is so bad or if it's cuz anything jay sings is beautiful in my ears, even if he makes mistakes. haha.
kewlpiggy88

[GaryDAI]

I never really even noticed. Gonna go watch it again though to see lol

[jAy is a s h y_ b o i]

he does that often.. he just repeats lyrics when he messes up!


like in the LV concert.. you know during "long quan" where he does the Chinese opera thing?

Jay sang the opera too early in the song.. before the music break. so he ended up doing it twice. ^^

[cici bebe]

hehe in the latest news article at multistars Jay says that because he sings so vague (ehm unclear) that he's able to slip by his mistakes because sometimes the audience can't hear him. ;D

he does cover them well.. i think i would have just laughed on stage! :p

[babyxv]

i noticed a lot of mistakes when he sang Jian Dan Ai and Shanghai 1943. i didnt notice any on the fast songs though

jAy is a s h y_ b o i : whoa i went to the LV concert and didnt notice that he did the opera thing at the wrong time!

jay... so talented in SO many ways

[t0kg0nG]

oh no.... i watch d vcd 30 times n i onli noticed his kai bu liao kou's fault... i tink he realli hide it up vv welll.... or probabli im juz 2 engrossed wof his music.. haha...

[t0kg0nG]

oh no.... i watch d vcd 30 times n i onli noticed his kai bu liao kou's fault... i tink he realli hide it up vv welll.... or probabli im juz 2 engrossed wof his music.. haha...

[gialinh805]

hahaha jay actually messes up with lyrics a lot...even with other performances. but yea he says its b/c he gets nervous hehe. he does cover pretty well though. i remember the las vegas concert when he was singing anjing. to mess up for a song like that wouldnt be too good...it was pretty obvious he sang the wrong thing and it was kind of exciting to hear what he'll he to cover up. haha he jsut made up some weird stuff...some was from some other verse, others i dont know where it came from lol. but yea its cool i mean his lyrics are really hard anyway, and its understandable when you ahve to perform in some many people. i think when you think about the lyrics, you kind of panic about whats next and forget it

[grasshow]

but it's not really that surprising if he messes up.. imagining doing, like 20-23 songs in one show, and with all the dancing and stuff.. it's a lot to do.. plus i think jay's not all that comfortable doing huge shows.. i read an article where he said that he wished to do shows where it's just him, a piano, some fans.. it's a good idea, he should do an mtv unplugged session, how good would that be...

[toynbee7]

I found that he never sang Quiet with exact lyric that he wrote on various live shows and some other songs like Ban Dao Tie He as well. But those songs with much more complicated words that written by Fang, he can almost remember well, such as Grandpa's Tea, really funny, anyway, he's able to cover those mistakes well and pretend that he perform rightly.

[toynbee7]

I found that he never sang Quiet with exact lyric that he wrote on various live shows and some other songs like Ban Dao Tie He as well. But those songs with much more complicated words that written by Fang, he can almost remember well, such as Grandpa's Tea, really funny, anyway, he's able to cover those mistakes well and pretend that he perform rightly.

[vinka]

Hmmmm didnt he also made some lyrics up while singing Anjing in Taiwan? He does it a lot in many of his songs and I find it pretty amusing That is what truly makes watching a concert more worthwhile because you get all this surprises that you will never find listening to his cds or watching his video. Btw, I agree that because he sings in a mumbling style, fans cant really tell if hes messing up the lyrics and of course we can never notice it during the fast songs because I, myself cant reallt figure out what hes saying because his rapping is too fast for me.

I dont know if any of you noticed but in Vegas he changed the pitch in singing Fen Lie. The original pitch of the song is very low and he started low but after one line he switched one octave higher and by the chorus, which is a higher pitch he returned to the original pitch.
My friend who watched the concert in singapore said he did the same thing there. But he didnt do it in taipei, though.
In any case, hes an extremely good performer....and hes cute, too =)

[lovejay]

but it's not really that surprising if he messes up.. imagining doing, like 20-23 songs in one show, and with all the dancing and stuff.. it's a lot to do.. plus i think jay's not all that comfortable doing huge shows.. i read an article where he said that he wished to do shows where it's just him, a piano, some fans.. it's a good idea, he should do an mtv unplugged session, how good would that be...

yeah and i hope that'll be in singapore too :love:

[Ziwei]

if it's just him n few fans..... err..he got so many fans.... then hw to accomodate? wait the fans fight.. hehe..

btw, it was till i go c the lyric while listening to The One live cd then i realise that he sang wrongly! if nt i really cant tell.... no matter hw many times i listen to them..... hmm.. am amused...

[Serendipity]

but it's not really that surprising if he messes up.. imagining doing, like 20-23 songs in one show, and with all the dancing and stuff.. it's a lot to do.. plus i think jay's not all that comfortable doing huge shows.. i read an article where he said that he wished to do shows where it's just him, a piano, some fans.. it's a good idea, he should do an mtv unplugged session, how good would that be...

yeah and i hope that'll be in singapore too :love:

Just the thought of this makes me wanna faint! :love:
If only man... close up to Jay, listening to him sing... Heaven!
But I bet the tics would go at exorbitant prices then... and some fans would probably not be able to contain themselves and start getting all... groupie! Then it wouldn't be such a musical thing anymore... :(

[sUm^MeR]

WHoaaa, I smiled a lot when watching it. He totally messed up in Shanghai 1943, That soooo obvious.
In Kai Bu Liao Kou, I sang along with him when watching and realize.... Ooops, he messed up!!!
In Jian Dan Ai, he got messed up too. So cute and funny, he said he doesn't sing it often and ask the audiences to sing louder with him.
And if you notice in An Jing..., there is very minor mistake. When he should be singing,

WO MEI YOU ZHI ZHONG TIAN FEN
BAO RONG NI YE JIE SHOU TA

He sang it
WO ZHEN DE MEI YOU TIAN FEN
BAO RONG NI YE JIE SHOU TA

I realized it when I heard the Live CD while singin along with it in my car and realize... hey he messed up. Well, this one I bet no one notice. :)

And out of topic a little bit. When in the Pepsi Concert in HK, he messed up when singing LONG JUAN FENG. So cute.... he pretended that nothing happened.

[blue_ice]

huh....did he forget the lyrics...i feel tt he sang well thO...in kai bu liao kou...i feel that its really nice....i dont feel tt there mistakes leh...:p

[nunchakus]

For the Live VCD: I guess as have been mentioned already, the most prominent mistake was in Shanghai 1943...heheh. But I like his made-up version as well. He also sang Ni Zhe Me Lian Hua Dou Shuo Bu Qing Chu differently.

Now I have a question and I wonder whether anyone else noticed. I first bought the The One DVD and his version of An Jing there was WAAAAAY OFF. But then, when I saw The One VCD, he sang An Jing just fine. Anyone else noticed the difference? I've been mystified to say the least...Unless he repeated the song twice...

:?:?:?

[joan]

actually the first time. i watched the vcd, i din find any mistake.. until i sing it along with him and with the lyrics booklet in my hand, then i found that got a number of songs he forgot the lyrics... i think they are the jian dan ai, an jing, kai bu liao kuo... even he sings wrongly, i tink he covered himself up very well as he din show out that he forget the lyrics.. but never mind. even he forget his lyrics.. his singing is still great...agree?

[rachelle03]

Now I have a question and I wonder whether anyone else noticed. I first bought the The One DVD and his version of An Jing there was WAAAAAY OFF. But then, when I saw The One VCD, he sang An Jing just fine. Anyone else noticed the difference? I've been mystified to say the least...Unless he repeated the song twice...

:?:?:?

actually i oso noticed that. I saw THE ONE on the net, way b4 the official VDC/DVD came out (later i realised, it's actually a bootleg version released in China, coz "fen lie" was listed as "li kai") N i muz admit jay was not very gd. The 1st time i heard him perform An Jing so out of tune. Then when i bot the vcd, it sounded fine. there's actually rumour saying jay actually re-sang during re-recording of the concert. :rock:

[nunchakus]

Now I have a question and I wonder whether anyone else noticed. I first bought the The One DVD and his version of An Jing there was WAAAAAY OFF. But then, when I saw The One VCD, he sang An Jing just fine. Anyone else noticed the difference? I've been mystified to say the least...Unless he repeated the song twice...

:?:?:?

actually i oso noticed that. I saw THE ONE on the net, way b4 the official VDC/DVD came out (later i realised, it's actually a bootleg version released in China, coz "fen lie" was listed as "li kai") N i muz admit jay was not very gd. The 1st time i heard him perform An Jing so out of tune. Then when i bot the vcd, it sounded fine. there's actually rumour saying jay actually re-sang during re-recording of the concert. :rock:

Bootleg version?!!??!? Ahhh!!! *stabs herself* I bought it immediately when HMV released it. And it was so ex...after a few months, the price outside dropped to about 1/3 of the initial price! But it's ok. Anything for Jay. :) I read somewhere that the song title had to be changed to Li Kai because of some red tape thing in China (though I can't firgure out what)...I think Jay once explained before.

Wow...resang?...Well, I suppose that is highly possible..But I suppose we must ask fans who were there live to really judge. :unsure:

[jim]

yah, i do buy the SO CALL BOOTLEG version... and the Silence sung.........damn jialat......... but when the actual vcd come out... they edited away already.... i thot there are 2 different concert... but he is damn good i would said...... dono when he will mess up with , BAN SHOU REN, NINJA< SHUANG JIE KUN and LOONG QUAN.............. haha, if he did a remix version of these song, swapping the script...wowo that will be great......

[sUm^MeR]

yah, i do buy the SO CALL BOOTLEG version... and the Silence sung.........damn jialat......... but when the actual vcd come out... they edited away already....

Now that you mention the editing, Did they also edit his Fen Lie too??? B'coz when I watched the VCD, his voice doesn't match his mouth gesture. I thought he was lipsync-ing, but maybe he wasn't. They just edited it afterwards. Was there any difference in Fen Lie between the bootleg version and the official version??? Anyone??? :?

[GoNgZhu]

i also noticed dat too, his singing didnt relli match his mouth!!!!!
i just thought it was da bakground sining or something, mayb they did patch tat one up too!!!!
i didn relli notice ne mastakes until now!!! very good improvizing tatz for sure!!!

[minimin]

I think that they did mention in the news that Jay have some probelm with his mic...it wasn't responding good so maybe that's the probelm. But i think Jay won't lipsync because he said that he wish to be able to sing live all the time and it wasn't his fault right? It's the mic probelm. I first thought he lipsync too but after reading that new after the concert I said I wouldn't mind for that. Also Jay always admits that he forget lyrics maybe that's why he have problem maybe sometimes adding his own stuff. But Jay also said before that everytime he do a song live he hope to make something different about it becasue he said what's the meaning of singing the same thing when when you can hear it in the cd.

[SpLinX]

there r mistakes in Ban Dao Tie He & Shanghai 1943.If u listen carefully in the Ban Dao Tie He, u will notice that he got the lyrics b4 that " wei she me zhe yang zi......" part a bit mixed up at the start.

[nino]

hahaha....jay is so adorable, not afraid to make mistakes or maybe he just handles it well...i can't really tell whether he messes up or not becuase his lyrics are hard i haven't been able to sing along yet... :blush:

[nastynas]

Are you guys talking TheOne conert in Taipei?

[An9el**]

sometimes he do forget lyrics ...
he's human wat .........
hehe ...i didn really notice any mistakes in that vcd ..cos i just watch it once =)

[OLive_aNN]

in jian dan ai..
his mistake was very obvious bcoz he sang differently with the backing vocal

[vivien]

i almost cringed and died when i saw his vcd. maybe it's the quality of the disc, but he sang off-key, forgot lyrics, voice broke in the high parts, and he knows it too... the last part in kai bu liao kou, just b4 he left the stage, he tried to sing with force, and his voice broke horribly.
then in an jing, he couldn't concentrate on playing the piano and singing at the same time, he fumbled his lyrics and started making up new ones that dun make any sense. you can jus see it on his face that he's really mortifed himself.
the first few songs like shuang jie kun and ban shou ren, it looked like he was lip-synching, cos he's pretty bad at lip-synching, everyone can see through it.

the bad stuff said, i like his rendition of shanghai1943 more than the one in the cd, and also his hei se you mo. i think it's becouse the concert was too large-scaled, they couldn't coordinate everything in time, that's why the mic, ear-piece, lip-synching part all blotched things up.
having said that, he's still pretty good in live shows, just need more time to practise and improve.

[GuArDiAn AnGeL]

shanghai 1941 was the most obvious...!!...thats for sure....cuz he like mumbled pretty much the last part of the first and second line ^^;;; but at least that way we know that he wasn't just mouthing the words and have his cd play on the back.....^^