PDA

View Full Version : [SG Entertainment] Talk about the Singapore Idol 2006 here!


yUkLuM^
05-22-2006, 05:16 PM
hey singapore idol is here again... any of your friends got in? haha i thought maybe we can start a thread to discuss about the contestants... saw the auditions and i think the funniest one is the "nong nong ago" person... what do u all think?

cacky
05-22-2006, 05:17 PM
Errrrrrrrrm, think you got a typo error on your title. You may wanna consider changing the year.

Tidus
05-22-2006, 05:26 PM
yeah it should be 2006 :P

Anyways, i find that kungfu guy, really funny... its like when the judges told him that he aint singing, the kungfu dude told them he is actually rapping, and goes about explaining what rap is about to the judges. I mean... oh come on, do you think the judges are noobs? lol

Its when the judge asked him out, did he finally try to sing a slow song, but still failed it. weird people lol..

Btw to those that played Dota, dont you think the first contestant shown on tv, the one that they mention having lip gloss all over his face, dont you think he reminds u of pudge the butcher? one of the hero characters in dota.. lol

liwei_jay
05-23-2006, 02:13 AM
haha...
Singapore Idol..
i couldn't stop laughing when i watch the show.. :lolabove:
some of the contestant are really entertaining..
i saw alot of potential and :thumbsup: ones..

wonder if it's really true that this time round gonna be another male idol.. :shifty:

jacelyn_edison86
05-23-2006, 04:14 AM
when i watch the singapore idol. i found the first contestant was so funny,he puts on lips gloss....... when he rubs the lip gloss from his mouth, it smears to his face and he's a real joke for the day to the judges.......
there's another contestant. she didn't pronounce the world properly and that contestant makes me laugh till i fall of my bed....... so funny..... :P

piglet
05-23-2006, 03:22 PM
i did not catch the last Singapore Idol until the final competition between Taufik and Sly..

so i watched this round audition on Sunday...haha..

the most 'impressive' is that guy playing hola-hoop..Dick Lee actually asked him to GET OUT..Hahaha.. ><'

i like that part when they showed the most popular song..many different competitors were singing the same song and they showed them singing one phrase each..and in the end, they sing together..i was like..wow! it was well-arranged..hee hee..

and when they get to next rounds, those outside waiting friends scream so loudly that someone commented that they should book a bus here next time..so many supporters!!

would try to catch this show for the coming weeks..if not, i shall come back to this thread for updated news..hahaha

DragonPrince
05-23-2006, 07:00 PM
I think the Mental Hospital is going to earn big bucks. We can see many mad people around, if we see them. We can send them to the hospital and they can earn big bucks after.

Its so scary to know that there are many mad people in our country. You guys have to be careful at all times.

I pity the judges.

TRUTH
05-23-2006, 11:57 PM
The idol mania is here again...can't stop the flow of the media and competition in Singapore,when will it stop?after project superstar 2...because I wanna join it..lol:-)

liwei_jay
05-24-2006, 02:31 AM
Keith..
you're joining the Proj Superstar 2??
:brows:
Good luck.. i'm sure you'll find alot of your supporter from JCNET here.. :P
juz to root for you.. *woots*

cacky
05-24-2006, 03:42 AM
I think the Mental Hospital is going to earn big bucks. We can see many mad people around, if we see them. We can send them to the hospital and they can earn big bucks after.
Its so scary to know that there are many mad people in our country. You guys have to be careful at all times.
I pity the judges.

Hhahahhahaha, yeah, I agree with you. There are indeed a lot of mad people in Singapore, just that I never expect them to be so young. I have a feeling that these people are planted lah.

I mean, how can they be so thick-skinned? Some of them obviously can't sing? I always wonder what's the reason behind joining?

Were they hoping to be able to improve after getting through the auditions? I mean, they can't even make it through auditions with those vocals.

DragonPrince
05-24-2006, 03:51 AM
Keith! Another photo from you as your avatar! When you are an idol, I don't think you have the time to log in here. But be sure to take a good picture and autograph it after you become a star. And oh, welcome back.

Cacky, thanks for the agreement. I admire the spirit of coming back again and again to try. But some people are trying too hard, I think they should seriously take a break. LOL

chapman
05-24-2006, 06:08 PM
I didnt catch the 1st episode till the encore telecast yesterday... hehe..

The nong nong ago girl, kept me on stitches.. hehe.. The kungfu guy is defintely trying to pull a fast one and get media attention.. sheesh and he sang the rap, disgracing jay's song..

So is anyone from sg idol in JC Net?

cacky
05-24-2006, 06:15 PM
Well, I am NOT in Singapore Idol, hahahhaha but my friend's cousin is Gayle Nerva. She made it to the next few rounds so watch out for her, kay? She's got potential!

DragonPrince
05-24-2006, 07:37 PM
I don't know who is who. I will watch all the funny parts and leave the rest alone.

But after watching those funny and crazy people, I am starting to feel that Singapore is not safe anymore. *sobs!*

jacelyn_edison86
05-25-2006, 05:21 AM
hum....
WY you only watch the funny parts. I watch the show till it finish and i laugh from the begining of the show till ending cause those people were so entertaining..... must watch it on sunday,want to see how Dick Lee critic people.....

Wendy
05-26-2006, 03:57 PM
Yup.. I catch the show too.. actually I just wanted to watch the auditions episode, cos its so funny.. :lolabove:

I think the lady who can't even pronounce correctly is the one who said "Campfire In The Moonlight". LOL..

And the part which they compare the cowboy guy and the chinese guy who sang.. i mean rap, shuang jie gun.. i was :glug:

However, i think it was brave for them to go there and be ridiculed by so many ppl.. just for the few seconds of fame.:happy:

jacelyn_edison86
05-27-2006, 09:11 AM
i wonder why the girl pronounce the song title wrongly, are she having pronouncing problem. She makes me laugh till i fall from my bed and i got scolding from my sister because i was laughing so loud. can't control it.

cacky
05-29-2006, 03:38 AM
Anyone knows where I can watch last night's episode online? I am not in Singapore now.

liwei_jay
05-29-2006, 06:52 AM
:hmm:
Cacky,
did you try the SI webbie??
try it and see :wink2: www.singaporeidol.com

yUkLuM^
06-03-2006, 03:31 PM
oh i heard from my juniors that paul twohill is from cat high... actually i think he got the X factor and he has got his own style... hope he can get into the finals... haha although its still long... joakim gomez is from my sister's school... heard that he is quite popular in school... but i dont think he sings well... :rolleyes:

Wendy
06-04-2006, 07:16 AM
Now that the auditions rounds are over, and its time to begin the competition. I don't think I will continue to watch the show cos I'm more interested in chinese songs rather than english songs (no offence there, anyone..) But I will still catch the final episode, when the birth of the 2nd Singapore Idol happens.

cacky
06-04-2006, 06:25 PM
Is Gayle Nerva still in??? Anywhere i can download the episodes? I can't find them on Singapore Idol website.

DragonPrince
06-04-2006, 07:21 PM
I don't know if you can find it. I heard that the Mediacrop website are often attacked by hackers and thus, making the file corrupted.

Yes, I am not watching it anymore too. I only like the funny parts.

becauseofYOU
06-09-2006, 09:12 AM
Gayle Nerva rocks! :D Jasmine is all right.. but seriously she bores me. Does anyone else think so?

Starylosophy
06-09-2006, 12:31 PM
Rahima Rahim and Jasmine Tye are through to the top 12.

The top four contestants last night were Geraldine Chua and Gayle Nerva and the above two who got through.

jacelyn_edison86
06-09-2006, 03:08 PM
Yay,Rahimah is still in. Like her voice.Thank god,Milly Koo and another girl didn't get in.

sean-eka
06-10-2006, 06:46 AM
Is Gayle Nerva still in??? Anywhere i can download the episodes? I can't find them on Singapore Idol website.

Sting has some downloads in the DL forum.
and oh, if im not wrong, an ex-student from my school got into Singapore Idol.
i forgot what's her name, but, she got through because of the song, 'how do i live' that she sang.

The MCR look-alike can sing really well!

cacky
06-11-2006, 07:37 AM
Thanks sean-eka. I'll try to look around.

Oh man!!!

Why did Jasmine get in??? I saw small clips. She so expressionless and woody!!!

Gayle was just nervous that night, according to my friend. He was there and apparently, they cheered really loudly in the beginning that caused her to miss her cue. She was clearly upset becoz' of that.

Guys, if you really think she's good, please vote for her to give her your support. I think this gal's got potential. She has got the looks too.

jacelyn_edison86
06-11-2006, 08:33 AM
I think her voice is not bad but on that night she choose the wrong song to sing! She shouldn't have choose Alicia Key's song because most of her song is high keys and she can't really cope up with the keys of the song so well.

cacky
06-26-2006, 03:55 PM
Hi guys ... need your help to rally support for my friend's cousin Gayle Nerva ... she has gotten into wildcard and would need your votes in order for her to get into Top 12. Please do vote for her this Wednesday night if you think she is good and deserves to be in!

Thanks in advance!

ene
08-03-2006, 03:12 PM
Oh dear. Just saw this thread. Gayle is out :cry: and now, just like NOW, Jay Lim is out. But I don't think he can sing so it's ok.

I like Jonathan Leong :love: Me thinks he's hot. And he can sing. He's got the whole package, man.

At least he made me send 2 sms to support him. And I've never EVER been a Singapore Idol fan :rolleyes: How's that for support?

And btw, am I the only one who thinks that Jacintha (the judge) is like, out of her mind? I cringe everytime it's her turn to speak!

TRUTH
08-03-2006, 04:22 PM
Ja tries to comment with depth and value..but she can't!!I'm partially sick of singapore idol because of her...

jon is hot...

rahimah's cute!!!...lol..partially because she used to be my neighbour..:-)

Starylosophy
08-03-2006, 05:21 PM
There are alot of critisisms on her judging. I too, get frustrated why she has the problem of saying her comments.

Sometimes her comments are just useless. :dry:

jacelyn_edison86
08-04-2006, 03:24 AM
O.o
I didn't know that Jay Lim was kicked out!!!
so happy he was out as I think he's a bit too old for the competition!!!
I'm gald Joakim and Rahimah is still in!!!
Joakim rockz!!!

TRUTH
08-05-2006, 04:15 AM
Jay Lim has a very diverse voice..much as would like him to stay in this compeition..he is not suited for this idol thing as he utimately doesn't have the voice to compete with contenders like rahimah...hady..Jonathan...too hard for him to compete with them...:wink2:

ene
08-05-2006, 11:46 AM
Yes. I wish Ja would just either keep her comments to like 2 lines or just smile and say "good job". I wonder if she's on crack sometimes, with all those out-of-the-world comments :rolleyes:

Am not a big fan of Joakim though. Yes, he's got the pretty-boy, idol package but he can't really sing. And he just doesn't have that "edge" to be an idol, in my opinion.

Hady's pretty good as well. Was surprised that he could actually....sing!

TRUTH
08-05-2006, 06:59 PM
Hady can sing...that's for sure...Jonathan is a strong contender..but can he hold on to it?I'll be watching on for sure...

ene
08-06-2006, 05:45 AM
Jonathan is a strong contender..but can he hold on to it?
Sighs. You know what I'm afraid of ? That Paul will become the idol. Because I know that A LOT of teens out there think he's oh-so-cool. And who are the ones who bother to vote?

The teens.

I know a lot of Jon supporters out there but do they *actually* pick up the phone to vote? Not many.

So yeah, you're right. If the contest was based on judge's decision, Jon would have a very high chance. But this contest is based on people voting so even if he's awesome, it still boils down to how many people in Singapore are voting!

chewy
08-14-2006, 09:27 AM
I think itz not as interesting dis time round as compared to the first....so i didnt catch much of it on tv....

Wendy
08-15-2006, 05:32 AM
i didn't watch it as much as i did for singapore idol 1. Saw the results show last week.. well, rahimah was out.. and joakim was in tears.. what's going on between the two of them? I heard there's some rumours going on somewhere..

I never really watch their performances before.. but i think that, paul right? i can't see his face like 99% of the time. :hmm:

TRUTH
08-15-2006, 10:46 AM
This week's theme is ...ROCK!!

Watch out for jonathan...hardy...and mathilda...gonna rock the house!!

ene
08-19-2006, 11:12 AM
OMG. I can't believe that Mathilda's out ! :shock: She was one of the powerhouses of the competition and she's...out! When she was in the same "dangerous" group as Jon and Hady, I was like "Noooooooooooooooo!!!" because I didn't want ANY of these 3 to be out. Honestly, in my opinion, they are the best 3 singers of the competition and I cannot understand how they are always at dangerous group.

Then again, alot of the Joakim/Paul fans are teenagers who will be making like 25,678 calls to support them while the Hady/Jon fans are probably people who can appreciate good singers (ie. older teengers, adults, etc) who may support them quietly on tv but will not actually call in to vote.

That's so sad. I swear, the moment Jon is out, that's the end of me watching SI.

Miss ene <3 Jon :love:

cacky
08-20-2006, 03:10 AM
Oh my goodness ... that Jasmine is still around? She can't sing! Even though I haven't been following but am wondering why is she still around ... someone please tell me.

Nprob
08-20-2006, 01:24 PM
I don't follow this contest bcuz i'd never watch tv,he he.But yesterday i just watched some scene of it on the bus.I feel to like one guy,i think chinese one and feel he's somehow looks like Jay.Dunno his name anyway,but i try to figure it out.

TRUTH
08-20-2006, 02:14 PM
...Jonathan and hady deserve their place...but they will not be keeping it for long if you guys supporting them don't vote...so yea..sad..:cry:

ho_yt
08-22-2006, 10:35 AM
Oh my Mathilda is out :cry:

I really felt she should stay in the competition, I acturally hoping the final 2 will be her and hady but looks is it will never happen anymore :sadangel:

I wonder why Joakim is still in, even though he is cute, but he can't sing, I can't wait to see him kicked out of the competition...

jay_fantasy8
08-22-2006, 12:19 PM
i don't know. i was really speechless when the bestest singers in the competition got the lowest number of votes. x) i mean look at rahimah and mathilda. i think they are way better than some of the singers (*coughfacecoveredwithfurcough*) that are still in the race.

i <3 hady and jon though. hopefully they can make their way to the finals. x)

ene
08-22-2006, 02:27 PM
I don't follow this contest bcuz i'd never watch tv,he he.But yesterday i just watched some scene of it on the bus.I feel to like one guy,i think chinese one and feel he's somehow looks like Jay.Dunno his name anyway,but i try to figure it out.

I believe you are talking about this guy - the one on the right?

http://202.172.234.170/singaporeidol/gallery/3/3-27.jpg

That's Jon or Jonathan Leong. He is one of the better singers of the competition but don't ask me - I'm biased :bleh: He has this really low singing voice that's really nice.

I don't really think he looks like Jay though - except the small eyes bit :angel:

I'm looking forward to a Jon vs Hady final. Fingers crossed now.

i think they are way better than some of the singers (*coughfacecoveredwithfurcough*) that are still in the race.
:D I believe Mr Facecoveredwithfur can be seen in the pic above too. I wonder how he doesn't walk into lamp-posts or fall into a hole or something :whistle:

And I really don't understand too, how the best singers are ALWAYS in the dangerous group! Like huh?!?! Are 99.9% of Singaporeans tone-deaf or something!?

breathles5
08-23-2006, 07:59 AM
its a real wonder where joakim gets all his supporters and i was just listening to radio the other day, and the djs were super sarcastic abt the whole idol thing, of how joakim manages to stay in the competition given his 'singing' skills. lets keep our fingers crossed and hope that Jon and Hady can make it to the top2. what we want is a REAL singer, not a CLOWN.

cacky
08-23-2006, 03:28 PM
Just finished an episode of it ... haven't watched it since ages ... and I must say, I'm pretty disappointed with the standards. Though I know it's pretty unfair to comment based on one episode. So far, I'd say those with potential are Jon, Nurul and Hady.

Jon does remind me a little of the young Alex Toh, I mean, with his style ... not his vocals though. And his eyes definitely do not resemble Jay, he resembles more of Rain! As for Nurul, she's like what Florence said, her vocals remind me of what I listen on a plane for in-flight entertainment which is really soothing.

Hady has the confidence and can carry it off well. And gosh ... I'm once again proven right that Jasmine TOTALLY CANNOT MAKE IT! Why is she still there???

ene
08-23-2006, 03:39 PM
what we want is a REAL singer, not a CLOWN.
Very well said. Like what Ken said to Jon, they are going to be competing on the INTERNATIONAL arena.

Would Singaporeans be proud of having Paul / Jasmine / Joakim as THEIR SINGAPORE IDOL? Sheesh. If Paul becomes the idol, the world is going to think there are NO hair dressers in Singapore :rolleyes:

I'm not even going into the Joakim issue. I have nothing against him per se but seriously, we need someone who can SING. Not someone who can stand in front of the stage and smile. We already have a lot of plastic-cardboard cut-out "pop stars" in the world. We don't need *another* one!!

And was I the only who had no idea what Paul was singing when he was singing 5566's song? Good choice of songs though. I mean, how hard is it to sing a boyband song? And amazingly, he managed to mess it up too (in my opinion).

Jasmine TOTALLY CANNOT MAKE IT! Why is she still there???
During her English song, she was totally struggling to hit the high notes.

Good gawd, please let the finals be a fight between Hady and Jon. Pleeeeeasse.

Anyone guessing who will be out tomorrow? :wink2:

liwei_jay
08-23-2006, 04:24 PM
And I really don't understand too, how the best singers are ALWAYS in the dangerous group! Like huh?!?! Are 99.9% of Singaporeans tone-deaf or something!?

Ene dear,
you knw what i think...
Personally i think majority of those who bothered to vote for them are immature kids who doesn't even knw how hard it is to earn money..
and wasted their montlhly bills money by voting on some stupid looking guys just because they felt that he/she is looking good..

sighs.. kids nowadays..
i don't knw what they are thinking...
i'm sure majority of the adults wouldn't agree with the current results.. :whistle:

Wendy
08-23-2006, 04:34 PM
Well.. i've watched tonight's show.. (because of the asian pop)..
Wow.. Hady can really sing.. although i have no idea what he is singing.. (cos that's a malay song).. but its nice... *coughs.comparedtotherest.coughs*

And, Joakim sang xiao-wei.. haha.. its just weird... by the way, did u guys noticed that he closes his eyes everytime he starts to sing? Huh..?

ene
08-23-2006, 04:55 PM
And, Joakim sang xiao-wei.. haha.. its just weird... by the way, did u guys noticed that he closes his eyes everytime he starts to sing? Huh..?
I think he was trying to get into the....groove? :rolleyes: I have to admit, I just like shut off when I hear him sing. Or try very hard not to cringe. Seriously, if he is still IN the competition tomorrow, I will be seriously speechless.

Personally i think majority of those who bothered to vote for them are immature kids who doesn't even knw how hard it is to earn money..
and wasted their montlhly bills money by voting on some stupid looking guys just because they felt that he/she is looking good..
You're totally right. A lot of them are frantically voting for Paul because he's "soooo hot and has so much character". A lot of them are voting for Joakim because he's "soooooo cute!!!!". But can they sing? I think we all know the answer.

As for the adults who actually support the ones who can sing, are they voting? No. I know at least TWO persons who actually support Jon but when I cajole them to vote, they're like er, nope. I only support him mentally :rolleyes:

That's why people like Hady and Jon are *always* in the dangerous group. Sighs.....

jielun_
08-23-2006, 05:25 PM
when i first heard the final 12 sing, i expected hady, jonathan and rahimah to be the top 3.

but rahimah's out...

anyway, i just want hady to win! and yes i agree with ene, the final two should be hady and jonathan. hey, at least it'll be worth watching! you know if joakim and jasmine somehow make it to the grand finale, i'm so gonna just. DIE.

for your info, i literally RUN away from the tv the moment joakim sings. i know this is going to sound really mean but you know the thing joakim does with the mike stand every week? i hope he hits someone on the head with it. that'd be interesting.

certain fans should really start growing some ears and LISTEN before voting blindly.

i don't particularly support anyone, but i think Hady deserves the title the most and he's capable of representing singapore in World Idol (if they're even gonna have it anw), followed by Jonathan.

please don't flame me, just my two cents. =\

ene
08-24-2006, 02:43 AM
but you know the thing joakim does with the mike stand every week? i hope he hits someone on the head with it. that'd be interesting.
:roll: This cracked me up. I can't put a finger to it but what he does when he sings just doesn't go down too well with me too. I guess I just can't buy into his "cutesy" look :rolleyes:

Nah, you won't be flamed. A forum is to share views! I believe matured posters will not be going "NO NO!!! YOU MUST VOTE FOR XXX".

Personally, I'm rooting for Jon. I can totally see him on the world stage. And like I keep saying to anyone who'd listen, I <3 Jon :love:

:roll:

liwei_jay
08-24-2006, 03:08 AM
I actually have not much qualms against most of the singers that are ard now..
:rolleyes:
well.. they could sing..
just not as well as those which has been voted out.. (e.g. Rahimah, Mathilda)

It really saddens me to see what kinda ppl would represent singapore in This yr's SG idol..

i guess this is all the adults fault for being stingy not wanting to waste money for this kinda money-cheating poll/voting which you wouldn't knw whether is true or not..
and also.. the young'uns majority are so BIG.. i doubt the matured ones vote would mean anything too.. *shrugs*

Starylosophy
08-24-2006, 06:35 AM
I can't comment too much since I didn't watch most of the spetaculars. The TV was just on and occassionally I just listened teeny bits of it.

But I think from yesterday's spectaculars, the best vocals will go to Hady and Jon. The others weren't too good. I didn't like Joakim when he was on the top 24. I didn't understand why he got the chance to be on the top 12 at that time and even till now he's still there. Also, good singers are booted out instead.

It happens in every competition like this. I really think MDC should stop all these shows for sometime.

ene
08-24-2006, 03:34 PM
Hm....looks like another good singer got out of the competition. This time, it's Nurul. I mean, seriously, looking at Joakim, Jasmine, Paul and Nurul, I really don't see how Nurul is the one who got booted out today.

I guess we really can't underestimate the power of those young ones that it the redial button like 65,876 times :rolleyes:

Did anyone see Jon's face when they made the announcement that he was in? He didn't even hear it :D

Sheesh. I seriously have no idea who will be out next...any guesses?

jielun_
08-24-2006, 06:36 PM
Did anyone see Jon's face when they made the announcement that he was in? He didn't even hear it

LOL. i saw that! he looked so shocked! must be because he has been in the bottom 3 since god-knows-when and he didn't expect himself to be safe so fast.

my guess is that paul will be out next. actually, i think paul and jasmine are kinda unsafe because their performances are really unstable, they can be really good one week, but really bad the next. so i guess their stay in the competition will really depend on how well they perform. they can't make any mistakes or it's seriously "gone case".

but of course, i'd much rather joakim out... shucks, we got so close to getting him eliminated just now! what a pity.

and i agree with what ken said, i have faith that in the end, singaporeans will finally get it right and vote for the one who truly deserves it. (:

HADY! <3

TRUTH
08-24-2006, 07:52 PM
LOL. i saw that! he looked so shocked! must be because he has been in the bottom 3 since god-knows-when and he didn't expect himself to be safe so fast.

my guess is that paul will be out next. actually, i think paul and jasmine are kinda unsafe because their performances are really unstable, they can be really good one week, but really bad the next. so i guess their stay in the competition will really depend on how well they perform. they can't make any mistakes or it's seriously "gone case".

but of course, i'd much rather joakim out... shucks, we got so close to getting him eliminated just now! what a pity.

and i agree with what ken said, i have faith that in the end, singaporeans will finally get it right and vote for the one who truly deserves it. (:

HADY! <3Nice one!!haha...yea..I kinda agree with you..jon finally stays where he truly belongs..and JOAKIM!!...will be embrassed again on 8 days...grab a copy of it next monday...haha!!

natgw
08-25-2006, 10:44 PM
if only paul would cut his hair short.. its too much of a distraction already.. haha :tongue:

ene
08-26-2006, 08:41 AM
i think paul and jasmine are kinda unsafe because their performances are really unstable
Although they are unstable, I don't think they'd be out. They have FAR too many rabid fans voting 76,876 times for them each week. Then again, Joakim has such fans too so seriously, I have no idea who will be out next :worry:

Did you guys remember Florence's comment to Joakim? Something like how his fans should gently let him be out next week. :rolleyes:

I've got the copy of 8 Days. It has Joakim looking pai seh and one of Jon who appears in a hair magazine as a model ! Hehehe.

localhost
08-26-2006, 11:46 AM
those who sang very good have actually been voted out.

so do your actually vote for the idol you like or vote for those who sing really well?
(:

rgirl
08-27-2006, 09:42 AM
i just started watching singapore idol recently, and i must say that i'm rooting for HADY. his voice is better than the rest, and he sings best too. jonathan is not bad either, but his performances aren't that consistent. as in, he can sound really good in one performance but sound off in another performance.

the last week, i think that joakim or jasmine should have been out instead of nurul, cos she sounds better than them. but well, it's not usually based on the singing isn't it?

to be honest, i don't like paul. i know that he sings okay and stuff, but seriously i can't stand his hair. what's up with the long fringe? and the thing is, he wants to keep it that long, but everytime he does this head movement to get the hair out of his eyes. like seriously, if you don't want your hair to get into your eyes, then cut it already! it's getting on my nerves.

sorry if i offended anyone, it's just my opinion. still, i hope hady will win. =)

cacky
08-27-2006, 12:05 PM
I sometimes wonder if it's just a tactic pulled by all these organizers. As in ... they let those lousy ones continue to stay up there so that people like us get so fed up and get out of our butts and decide to send a SMS just to root for those people who truly deserve ... So as to increase more revenue for themselves.

Think about it, if those people who truly deserve to be out there are really out there ... then no one would bother voting, would they? So we should perhaps just take this whole thing as a game and not so seriously ... so as not to fall into their trap. Coz' the real good ones will ultimately win.

So far, results of these reality shows in Singapore haven't been disappointing right?

ene
08-28-2006, 03:51 AM
cacky You may actually be right. My friend was also saying that it's probably a tactic and that all these results are ultimately rigged anyway :rolleyes: As in, in the end, the winner will still be the "RIGHT" winner so it's a win-win situation. People keep voting to keep their idols in (ie. a lot of revenue) and it keeps the show exciting.

Hm.......:hmm:

zhoudaoyan
08-28-2006, 07:42 AM
ive.. never seen this thread b4! lol. but if i had i would have started posting in here already..

i watched the beginning part.. in singapore.. but then i had to come back to perth for school..
so ive been asking my uncle to record the eps for me and also watching them on youtube..

>< joakim has SUCH a good character.. have you guys been to his blog?? its soo touching. like all his posts are about feelings and deep stuff.. and it lets u see that he doesnt only have that bouncy side to him..
i think he looks a bit like wangleehom lol.

he's got the look, the charisma, and the moves...
and he's young..
okay.. thats what i thought before.. because i always thought that maybe JUST MAYBE his singing would improve..

but now i know its never going to happen.. sigh

jonathan though.. has talent. when he sings his powerful songs OMG its so nice it gives me shivers!! he has good vocals .. hes got the potential:D:D and he's so funnY! if you read his interviews and stuff hahaha.

ene
08-28-2006, 08:55 AM
>< joakim has SUCH a good character.. have you guys been to his blog?? its soo touching. like all his posts are about feelings and deep stuff.. and it lets u see that he doesnt only have that bouncy side to him..
:hmm: Call me a cynic but I can't help but wonder how much of what he writes in his blog is real. I can only judge his "singing" and seriously, I'm AMAZED at how far he has gone in the competition!

Jon is funny. He seems to actually look like he's having fun out there. Oh well. One can only hope the Singapore votes for the RIGHT idol :rolleyes:

Anyway, for those who want to read the idols' blogs, you can find it here (http://www.singaporeidol.com/blogs.htm).

zjie
08-30-2006, 11:00 AM
i think that now SG idol leftover are not as good as those who left...i dont really like Paul Hilltwo..especially when he swing his hair around..but i heard from people that he singing was quite good...i support more on Jonathan leong "same name as my friend aka Jonathan Soh)..haha..and the judges even say him as Jay No.2..i dont feel it that way..

ene
08-30-2006, 04:08 PM
i dont really like Paul Hilltwo
:D His name is Paul TWOHILL. He sounded really bad tonight, btw. Looks like he had an overdose of medication or something (he's sick apparently).

Oooh, Jon sounded great when he did "Unforgettable".

And wow, Hady IS good. He seems to handle the different genres very well, week after week!

Who do you think will be out tomorrow? :?

skueshy_noodle
08-31-2006, 05:55 AM
i think that singapore idol's standards are quite low.. for those serious talent seekers, the expectations are not met.. and it all matters on popularity which is quite unfair for those who can sing really well.. it's really very unpredictable on who will win this year's singapore idol..

ene
08-31-2006, 03:01 PM
OMG!!!!! Woohoo! Jon, Hady and Jasmine are safe. I have predicted before that these will be the top 3 and I think that hope may be coming through :wink2:

When Joakim was announced to be out, I actually felt a tad sad. He's handled this whole episode really well. Handling all the criticism must have been difficult for a young boy like him.

cacky
08-31-2006, 04:26 PM
At some point in time, I did think that Joakim reminded me a little of the Project Superstar winner, Chen Wei Lian. :wink2:

TRUTH
08-31-2006, 06:16 PM
....kinda felt that This was the Night...joakim's gone...don't mourn...rejoice...cause...its a fair and dignified exit out off the compeition...

regina12
08-31-2006, 08:42 PM
I felt really nervous cos I couldn't watch the results show live. I woke up and my friend did not reply me as to who got out! So I switched on my computer and checked out the website. Woot! What can I say? Finally Joakim is out!

I hope Hady wins the Singapore Idol!

cacky
09-01-2006, 05:08 AM
Actually, I'd prefer Jonathan to win .... Coz Hady reminds me of Taufik. I do wish it's someone refreshing this time around. Whatever it is, Jasmine CANNOT remain there.

ene
09-10-2006, 03:04 AM
Actually, I'd prefer Jonathan to win .... Coz Hady reminds me of Taufik
Agree 100%! Seriously, Hady reminds me ALOT of Taufik and I don't want another Taufik!! :cry:

Anyway, I'd be happy regardless, as long as Hady or Jonathan wins. Jasmine has improved quite a lot but do you think Singapore wants a female idol? :hmm:

OMG. We're down to the last 3!! I'm rooting for a Hady vs Jon finals. How about you?

rgirl
09-10-2006, 04:04 AM
yeah. i don't mind either jonathan or hady winning. true, hady is similar to taufik. well, i've always thought that taufik's talent is very wasted, cos he's like gone now. to be honest, i think it's because he's a malay, so the market is smaller for him. not that i discriminate against malays or anything. hady is a good performer, but i have a feeling that he won't last that long, like taufik. jonathan will have more opportunities cos he can go to the chinese industry, but he seriously looks weird singing chinese cos he looks a bit eurasian. :oops: well, jasmine has inded improved, but i still prefer jonathan and hady for the finals.

icetears-
09-10-2006, 05:14 AM
Hahahas I don't really watch Singapore Idol, but I'm for Jasmine.

Like rgirl said, Taufik's wasted now :| & even Sylvester, who can't exactly sing very well, supposedly had a bigger market, but now the contract's been terminated already. I'm for the girl this time, cos I think she outshines the other two :D

yingyingxxx
09-10-2006, 09:55 AM
Hello!

I really can't choose between the 3! I like Hady though, he's like the strongest? And somehow I prefer Jasmine over Jonathan.. She has improved a whole lot! Well, quite excited for the next SI episode! :D Wonder which two would be in the finals :)

crazygirl48
09-10-2006, 06:51 PM
Now left 2 guy and 1 gal now..

Same as what happened 2 years ago....
Seems like Singaporeans prefer male singers than female singers....:bleh:
I have bad feeling that it will be a male vs male grand final again....

Hady and Jonathan have the edge as both of them can sing really well....

Jasmine only managed to improve at the very "last minute" which make her the weakest singer among the 3...

Just hope that viewers can vote wisely this season..:whistle:

deeyan
09-11-2006, 12:44 AM
wah Im so lost about Sg idol..what happened to Paul twoehil (how do u spell his name) ? When was he eliminated? are the 3 finalists good?

chapman
09-11-2006, 03:07 AM
hey deeyan,

check out the singapore idol website for more info on the 3 finalists.. Hady, Jasmine Tye, Jonathan Leong.

www.singaporeidol.com

Paul Two-hill was eliminated last week. I think the judges and fans cant stand his emo look. The last 3 standing are more mainstream.

I cant also decide on the last 3. All are good, but I have a sickening feeling that they will vote Jasmine out. Sigh. She was good but not as good as Hady and John. John had been a hot fave from the start, and Hady started with his "Lengenda" song, which really was emotional and touched my heart.

ene
09-11-2006, 03:58 AM
Paul Two-hill was eliminated last week. I think the judges and fans cant stand his emo look.
When it was down to Paul and Jon, I was seriously nervous. I mean, Paul has A LOT of rabid fans who would break their banks voting for him! Thankfully, Singaporeans came true and voted him out :rolleyes:

I have always thought this and it looks like it may come true. Me thinks that it will be a Hady vs Jon final. Which would be AWESOME. :bounce:

I <3 Jon! :love: Tee hee hee.

yingyingxxx
09-11-2006, 02:36 PM
Hmm, but it was quite sad when I saw Paul tear! Afterall he has been a fun and friendly SI contestant.. But anyway I guess it is pretty much a Hady vs Jon Finals! If Jasmine gets voted out, I think it's pretty sad too! :worry:

I mean, she has improved so much from the first round yes. But yeah, I agree with chapman, good but not as good as Hady/Jon.

Oh well we'll see! :-)

TRUTH
09-11-2006, 04:36 PM
There will be a surprise outcome..wait and see..

joyangel
09-12-2006, 08:12 AM
i think it is going to be like last year again.
taufik---hady
sly--- johnathan
jasmine---olinda

i think it will be hady vs johnathan.
and i hope hady wins cuz he has the best voice among all 3!!!

ene
09-14-2006, 03:23 PM
There will be a surprise outcome..wait and see..
Lalalalala. There is NO surprise outcome :D It is EXACTLY what I expected :

Hady vs Jonathan

Oh man, it'd be a nail-biting final :oops:

But it seems like no one is quite interested in Sin Idol this time round eh? I mean, look at how slow this thread is moving!! :whistle:

TRUTH
09-14-2006, 04:28 PM
no wonder there is no Singapore idol season 3...haiss..they scrape the damn thing..

yingyingxxx
09-14-2006, 04:47 PM
Yes really expected!
I hope Hady wins it :-) JonLeong's voice is kinda well, too low for me :oops:
Hady made my heart melt when he sang Desperado yesterday! :happy:
Can't wait for 24th September!
Oh and Jasmine seemed so strong and she didn't cry :D

jay_fantasy8
09-15-2006, 02:27 PM
YAY. haha. i'm really looking forward to the final showdown. wahaha.

i dont know, but i think i'm rooting for err. you know, the one with the sexiest voice (jonjonjonjon). x) i caught bits of his perfomance on wed and last week, gosh, he sure knows how to capture the camera. hady's really good too, so i kinda want to see him getting the title. ahh. stiff competition.

but go jon. x)

crazygirl48
09-15-2006, 06:47 PM
Expected to be Hady vs Jon....
Same situation as 2 years ago...

Missed the show on Wed and shall catch the repeat on Saturday...:tongue:
I saw the 8 days magazine cover for this week that the SI3 will not take place???:wave:
How come?

stillcho
09-15-2006, 06:51 PM
GO JONLEONG!
I'll be rooting for him.

He makes all the girls go gaga over him!

:excited:

hqscreams
09-15-2006, 08:12 PM
i like jon but i think hady will win. lol both are good la (:

Wendy
09-16-2006, 03:43 AM
How come it's so similar to season 1? The final three is also 2 guys and 1 gal. Then, the final showdown is the 2 guys. And, there's something else... but i think i won't say it here.. :-)

IncomparableYX
09-16-2006, 04:30 AM
i think hady will win because jon's singing has no power.
But jon looks better so difficult to say lol.

ene
09-16-2006, 07:53 AM
OMGOMGOMGOMGOMGOMGOMG.

ene met Jon yesterday and Jon is just HOT. I thought his voice is low on tv but in real life, it was even lower! Wow.

Had a very short chat with him and man, all I could manage was "All the best Jon". I should have asked him to marry me :love:

I'd post up pix soon. I've got 2 like CLOSE UP shots of him smiling at the camera.

*fan girl mode*

OMGOMGOMGOMGOMGOMGOMGOMGOMG.

*faint*

yingyingxxx
09-17-2006, 03:06 PM
Haha seems like there are a lot rooting for Jon!
Looks like it's gonna be a close fight, definitely exciting :-)
How come everyone says Jon is hot! :D

stillcho
09-17-2006, 05:02 PM
Yeah, I think it's going to be a close fight.

And from my perspective, Jon's hot because he's got character/personality, the x-factor and he's really charming!!

icetears-
09-18-2006, 11:06 AM
I'm rooting for Jonathan Leong now! Cos I don't know, maybe all the raving here has pulled me over to his side x)

OMG okay I know I'm slow, but ummmmmmmm, when's the Finals? :X

ene
09-18-2006, 04:22 PM
How come everyone says Jon is hot!

He's hot because just look at this!!!


http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v327/ene_gal/jon1blog.jpg

I took this photo IN HIS FACE and he was like the sweetest, most charming "Idol" I've met. Ok, not that I've met any of the rest of the Idols but yeah, like what stillcho said here:

And from my perspective, Jon's hot because he's got character/personality, the x-factor and he's really charming!!

I have to totally agree. To me, he's not like DROP DEAD gorgeous or anything but he's got the whole package. Best of all, he's insanely down to earth, it's unbelievable.

And from a neutral point of view, I can see that he's extremely marketable, way more marketable than Hady. I don't hate Hady - he sings well but does it have that "IT" factor? Not to me.

To me, Jon is marketable because he's got the looks, the X-factor, the poise to answer questions at interviews, the brains to make sense when he speak, etc etc etc. You get my point.

ene <3 Jon.

OMG okay I know I'm slow, but ummmmmmmm, when's the Finals?
:D The finals will be on 24th Sep and the results show on 25th Sep, both at the Indoor Stadium.

Don't forget to vote! :wink2:

icetears-
09-20-2006, 11:15 AM
I will vote I will vote I will vote cos I didn't get to vote for sly the last time round since I was in camp.

GAAAHHHH OMG JON IS HOT :D

stillcho
09-20-2006, 03:07 PM
icetears-, SAME HERE!
I didn't get to vote for Sly previously!
Let's vote for Jon Jon Jon
:D

ene, I envy you! I wanna see Jon too!

ene
09-21-2006, 10:00 AM
I didn't get to vote for Sly previously!

Honestly, I don't see how Jon and Sly are alike. They're so different - except for the fact that both like rock? :? Then again, if Sly's fans all start voting for Jon, I don't have any complains. Hehe.

And yes, Jon is hot. He's even hotter in real life. And best of all, he's really down to earth and friendly. Amazing. :love:

I actually have more photos but it seems like no one here is interested in Singapore Idol eh? :worry:

I have one large poster along with his autograph stuck at my work cubicle. I also stuck a poster of him outside my cube so that whoever walks past will have to read "JONATHAN ROCKS!". Hahaha.

Oh and I even have a "We Love Jon" vote fund going on at work. My colleagues throw in their random change and so far, it's already enough for 12 votes ! Not bad eh? :D

Any Hady fans here?

ziai
09-21-2006, 01:22 PM
I dont know if anyone has posted this before... But anyway, this is Jonathan Leong's friendster...

http://www.friendster.com/jonleongfs

He has a blog there too!...

Here- http://jonleongfansite.blogs.friendster.com/jonathan_leongs_blogs_fro/

I think he writes it himself. I think

flamboyance
09-21-2006, 07:22 PM
hahaa. yeah man. those dudes just cant sing, but still they waste their own time. Oh my god.

yingyingxxx
09-23-2006, 05:35 PM
Haha seems like I'm the only one rooting for Hady!
It seems really weird that we only get to know the results on Monday and not on the day itself in the indoor stadium.
Gosh how exciting :-)

ene
09-23-2006, 08:02 PM
It seems really weird that we only get to know the results on Monday and not on the day itself in the indoor stadium.
Yeah, I know what you mean. Imagine being Hady and Jon. I would be totally sleepless on Sunday night! I think it's pretty cruel to wait one day for the results but I believe this is done to allow more time for people to vote.

Haha seems like I'm the only one rooting for Hady!
:D Nah, I don't think you're the only one supporting Hady. There are tons around ! Just that JC.net doesn't seem too keen on SI this time round and we have just been concentrating on Jon. :D

Oooh, a couple more hours to the big showdown!! :bounce:

How many times are you guys voting btw?

baka_amiz
09-24-2006, 05:01 AM
hi can i join in???
hmmm think everyone here is rooting for jon... me? i guess i support both hahazzz both have their own gd quality.
and about sly and jon i dont see the similarities except like some of u say both into rocks. but btw the two i like jon more. maybe jon has the more clean image. actually it seem this year spore idol the top 2 somehow is similar to the previous one. jon=sly hady=taufik.
so lets just wait for the final showdown today....

crescentgirl
09-24-2006, 07:51 AM
I think Hady's gonna win but still...there may be a discrimination of some sort. Seeing how this year's contestants are somewhat like last season's.

ene
09-24-2006, 12:24 PM
Will anyone be at the Indoor Stadium tonight? I just got offered 3 tickets to go but I saw the email late and then missed it!! :bang:

I'm so upset now.

Oh well, there's always the TV I guess. :cry:

hisashiluv14
09-24-2006, 03:57 PM
Okay, so I watched my second Singapore Idol episode tonight, which means that with the exception of an earlier performance (I think it was the top 8 one which sucked to high heavens) I had no prior knowledge of the contestants, didn't know anything about them, and more or less came in as as fresh viewer.

I hope I don't get stoned for saying this but I think Hady's the better singer. When he did that crappy original song, it actually sounded good and he took the inherent triteness and, well, crappiness out of the song. When Jonathan sang it I was just unimpressed and bored. I did like Jon's rendition of that Snow Patrol song and found his version of that local band's song pretty good, but Hady impressed me more on a higher level.

I guess for me it boils down to who has the wider vocal range - and I think it's obvious that Hady wins this one.

I'm probably going to vote once for Hady but I can't remember the SMS number right now and I'm a bit lazy so I'll think about it.

And no I'm not a Singapore Idol fan.

Also, just something that's perhaps of interest to the Jon fans here. I received an email in my NUS inbox from the admin, telling us about some appearance or whatever it was Jon had at the NUS University Cultural Centre. It basically told us to go down and support him. I guess this is an incentive for people to try to get into NUS. :-)

ene
09-24-2006, 05:08 PM
Also, just something that's perhaps of interest to the Jon fans here. I received an email in my NUS inbox from the admin, telling us about some appearance or whatever it was Jon had at the NUS University Cultural Centre. It basically told us to go down and support him. I guess this is an incentive for people to try to get into NUS.
I thought that already happened? Unless it's another one.

Anyhow, nah, you won't get stoned. We're all for free speech here (at least I am!) and you know what? I do agree with you that Hady does have a wider vocal range but to me, I see an idol as someone who can appeal to the mass market with a distinct voice. It's like when you hear Jay, you know it's Jay.

When I hear Jon sing, I know it's Jon. Despite Hady having a wide voice range which naturally means he can sing more songs, I still feel that Jon has that edge in terms of individuality and marketability.

That's my take, of course :D

stillcho
09-25-2006, 12:30 PM
When I hear Jon sing, I know it's Jon. Despite Hady having a wide voice range which naturally means he can sing more songs, I still feel that Jon has that edge in terms of individuality and marketability.
That's my take, of course :D

AGREED! I feel that way too!
I really hope Jon wins this, not because Hady is no good, but Jon is somehow more appealing and he just can connect with me so very well. (: plus his super low vocals, melt my heart after he sang "Chasing Cars". Or rather, all the 3 songs.

GO JON GO JON :excited:

Sorry to say this, but I felt the way Hady dressed yesterday = no style? He didn't have that SINGAPORE IDOL factor there, though I gotta admit he's got a really wide vocal range. And it's good indeed.

hisashiluv14
09-25-2006, 02:50 PM
I thought that already happened? Unless it's another one.


Yep it's the same one. It was sent out a while ago though. I just felt like mentioning it!

I'm too lazy to watch the result show so I'll check back here to see who wins. Haha.

I don't remember what Hady wore. I only remember that the two of them wore a lot of suit-like jackets (I don't know what they're called).

Actually I think I would've loved to hear Jon sing Matchbox 20's If You're Gone. Like I said I didn't watch the show so I only heard like half a line of it during last night's introduction recap thingy. It sounded pretty nice. I think he's quite suited for today's brand of mainstream rock. :)

ene
09-25-2006, 02:57 PM
The results show is now on and the phone lines are closed and my heart is in my mouth :cry: Man, this is nerve-wrecking!!

Check out Jon singing Snow Patrol's "Chasing Cars" here (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JpxtynwrYhA).

And he's singing Lee Hom's "Wei Yi" here (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BmtdPDnmyD0).

:love:

[edit]
Ok, so Hady won. Sighs. Kinda expected yet I can't help feeling disappointed. Hm.

rainbowballoon
09-25-2006, 04:45 PM
was not excited at all cause I didn't really 'chase' this season..

well history repeated itself taufik part II Hady won! But his voice is not bad.. anyway the judges comments for Jonathan seem to be more positive.

"Your journey has just begun, I agree with Dick you can be a regional star" whereas to hady: "You must make singapore proud" or something.

yingyingxxx
09-25-2006, 04:47 PM
Hmm congrats Hady! :-)
Sorry I feel very out of place haha cos there are like most people rooting for Jon! But oh man I really feel happy for Hady! :excited:

I think he did better than Jon for the You Gave Me Wings song! I was really very captivated by his performance, I liked it a lot :D
Anyway, I think this is quite a close fight. I'm sure the votes were pretty close. I think both of them did well so claps to both! :happy:

Do you all think this season's better than the previous?
To be honest I don't really know. The previous season seems really behind and I kinda have forgotten all about it haha :tongue:

I personally feel today's performance was more enjoyable than yesterday's. It was kind of a rush yesterday, 3 songs for Jon and Hady and that's it! :worry:

Oh I agree, rainbowballoon! The judges seem more positive towards Jon and I feel that they kinda prefer Jonathan.

characterxx
09-25-2006, 05:19 PM
I was hoping Jonathan would win ! but Hady put up a great performance as well..... kudos to both for a great job well done!

jeffyer
09-25-2006, 07:42 PM
quite disappointed bout the results but oh wells, its just a idol contest again.

cheers~

krystin
09-26-2006, 03:07 AM
Hady won :D Came as no surprise to me, I was testing out my teacher's hypothesis, and it is true. For all the jonathan fans out there, don't be dissappointed k?

here it goes..

In the previous singapore idol, taufik won. Maybe partially because of his talent, but more because of his better command of the english language. If he were to be sent to the world idol to compete, I think that taufik has got a better chance of winning because afterall, people judge you by the way that you speak and everything. So, it is the same for this time too. hady won because he is good at singing, and he has a better command of english over jonathan.

If you don't believe, wait till the next final 2 singapore idol, the same thing will happen again.

But i feel that it doesn't matter who wins, because ultimately, they are all winners for coming so far! they have managed to live their dreams and that's what counts :D

congrats hardy..

G3n3
09-26-2006, 04:25 AM
hardy? nah... i still prefer JAY all the way!

baka_amiz
09-26-2006, 06:25 AM
congrats to hady... and well done for jon too. think both have done very well in the competion.

krystin
hmmm... never really notice about their command of english... but in the first idol seasons, i had actually thought that they choose taufik maybe of the more çlean' look. sorry for sly fans here, but like you say if they were to send the idols to compete, i guess they want someone who is pleasent looking and those reflect well on singapore. sly has just those ah beng look.
as for jon and hady. i actually told my sis that jon is most probably to win. apart from singing, he has the package. term of look(hady has too) and education. thus i thought that jon will most probably the ideal person if to represent spore.
anyway both are winners and think they will advance in the showbiz industry from now on. and this will not only apply to the top 2 but maybe for the rest of the top 12 also.

and about yesterday result show, hady actually quite lay back during the performance. he seem not really as good as his past performance. I also notice that when hady, jon and taufik sang together, i think taufik is still the nicest of them in term of vocal(its just wat i think no need get angry ok jon n hady fan).

stillcho
09-26-2006, 10:51 AM
Disappointing. ): I wanted Jon to win.
Although I wasn't a really hardcore fan of Jon, I couldn't help but feel sad.
Oh well, luckily I wasn't as crazy this season compared to last season, if not I'd have cried so hard for Jon. Well, if Jon really wants it, I think he'll go really far, so Jon all the way! :D

Singapore Idol, HADY MIRZA.
*claps claps*

ho_yt
09-26-2006, 12:39 PM
Yay, Hady is the new Singapore idol!!

Acturally, I think both Jon and Hady are very strong, Jon has the X-factor and Hady's songs is very touching, but no matter who wins, its just a competition, so someone is going to be the winner...

bueytahan
09-26-2006, 01:57 PM
Yup. By this stage of the competition, I'm sure both them are already winners! =) I think the Singapore Idol song this year's pretty nice by the way. :-)

ene
09-26-2006, 05:54 PM
In the previous singapore idol, taufik won. Maybe partially because of his talent, but more because of his better command of the english language. If he were to be sent to the world idol to compete, I think that taufik has got a better chance of winning because afterall, people judge you by the way that you speak and everything. So, it is the same for this time too. hady won because he is good at singing, and he has a better command of english over jonathan.

I would have to disagree on that bit about command of English. I'd actually put my money on Jon having a better command of English. He was an SJI boy and from the interviews I've heard so far (being objective and all), he does seem to speak better than Hady. Hady seems to be always tongue-tied or lost for words!

But interesting theory though :wink2:

hisashiluv14
09-28-2006, 04:05 PM
Is there still World Idol anyway? If I'm not wrong there wasn't one last year. I don't think people have that in mind when they vote.

I'm glad, at least, that time time round the Chinese guy can actually speak English.

yingyingxxx
09-28-2006, 04:33 PM
Hmm come to think of it, if we compare our Singapore Idol to the others like American Idol.. it seems really far, isn't it. Like although I support hady :D But still, I can't help thinking that our standards can't match up with them. But then Singapore is so small, right!
Okay sorry if I'm going a little off topic. :oops:
Oh yes, our chinese can speak english this time round. :happy:

stillcho
09-29-2006, 10:20 AM
Hahahaha I agree. Our Chinese can speak English now.
Hahahaha Sylvester was...

And I realised a lot of people think Jon looks like an ahbeng but he's not!!!
Oh and Sly looks like an ahbeng, and he is one right!!!!

Actually come to think of it, Hady and Taufik may be similar, but Jon and Sly, I don't really think so \:

BlueChaos
09-29-2006, 12:52 PM
Hrrrrm... me and my friends support Jonathan, but in the end he lost... :oops:

Our theory of why he lost is maybe because he looks more like some HK or Taiwanese idol (reminds us of F4 actually), so he doesn't got a "Singaporean" look. So other than Hady's better vocals, his overall outlook as a Singaporean is better than Jonathan, despite many people saying that Jonathan is more handsome (well yes maybe he is, but he doesn't look too Singaporean actually).

So if he goes to World Idol (if any) he won't be mistaken as a HK/Taiwan Idol :bleh:

ene
09-29-2006, 02:21 PM
Actually come to think of it, Hady and Taufik may be similar, but Jon and Sly, I don't really think so \:
Yeah, I agree. I get annoyed when people say that Jon and Sly are similar. THEY ARE SO NOT SIMILAR PLEEEAASE. Besides both having long hair, I don't see any other resemblence.

Like what many have said, at least Jon can speak GOOD English :rolleyes:

Hrrrrm... me and my friends support Jonathan, but in the end he lost...
Sighs, yeah, me too. Voted quite a few times too but oh well, I guess we can't fight with Hady fans. I just read in 8 Days today. They interviewed people who they're voting for. Read on:

My family and I has decided to vote 600 times for Hady. That's $350 but we think he's worth it.
- Abdul Rahman, 33, financial consultant
OMG. $350?!?!?! That is just...insane.

I would spend $20 and vote for Hady just to save Singapore from that Jonathan. He's so monotonous.
- Chris Zikiff, 22, NSMan
Jon monotonous? Oh well. To each his/her own.

I'll vote once for Jonathan. I don't see the point in voting like a crazy fan. I'd rather donate the money to charity.
- Su-Yen, 21, Maarketing Executive
Sighs. See? How to win the Hady fans? This girl sums it all up, really.


Now we know why Hady won :sadangel:

stillcho
09-30-2006, 04:50 AM
No wonder...
70% and 30%, that's a REAL HUGE gap.

I thought Jon's fans would vote pretty hard, but I guess they are too confident he'd win? That's what I thought. I thought Jon would probably win this competition, but sadly, that wasn't to be.

yingyingxxx
09-30-2006, 12:30 PM
Yes, probably too confident that Jon would win! Even though I'm Hady's fan I actually thought Jon would win. Or if not, their votes would be a very small gap. Oh actually I did not vote like a lot for Hady. I only voted once. Guess I'm just not that much into Singapore Idol..

But this season's finalists are way better than the last, I think.

stillcho
09-30-2006, 06:51 PM
I am not very into this season's Singapore Idol.
I somehow feel that SI 2006 wasn't as big a hooha as the previous one. \:

Wendy
10-01-2006, 03:49 AM
Well.. throughout the whole competition, I only managed to catch less than 3 episodes, including the the grand finals... I do hope that Jonathan can win.. not that he's more good-looking, but, like what everyone has said, he got the X-factor.. however, being a runner-up, according to some previous competitions, the runner-up also gets publicity and who knows, he might come out with his own album, like that sly...

ene
10-04-2006, 02:22 PM
however, being a runner-up, according to some previous competitions, the runner-up also gets publicity and who knows, he might come out with his own album, like that sly...
Yeah that's true. But currently, it seems like the record company that is giving the contract to Hady (can't remember which one) is hesitate about signing on the runner up, for fear of the same thing happening to them like Sly's case (I think the contract ended before the time was up).

So I guess we can only hope that Jon gets a record deal soon! I do miss hearing him sing :cry:

icetears-
10-11-2006, 07:26 AM
Ene; Yeah they said it was a mutual decision. Gaahh it soudned like a really cheesy excuse to me.

I LIKE SLY'S HAIR :D

Okay back to SI. Sorry I'm gonna sidetrack a lil bit more. Did anyone read the papers today? There was an article about Taufik's I dream two years ago, that Leann Rimes sang it before, in 2001 or something. OMG that's like super zzzzzzzz O.O

Heartbeam
10-16-2006, 11:20 AM
Yes! I heard about it. Hahah, and my friend told me that the Leann Rimes version can be found on Youtube!

That said, I'm happy that Hady won :)