PDA

View Full Version : Singapore - 8 Days reviews Ye Hui Mei


ene
08-22-2003, 04:39 PM
The following review appears in Singapore, 8-Days magazine, page 73 :

'In the name of the father', the first lead song from this much anticipated album named after his mother, is admittedly a keeper, despite its lack of originality - the organ refrain that underscores the track is poignant and haunting, lending an air of Godfather-like intrigue to an average R&B composition.

The sampling of a bouncing ping-pong ball on the R&B/rap track, ' Class 3B', is also a cheekily brilliant touch. How very Jay Chou to take somethin from the western pop world and tweak it ever so cleverly. Much of the rest of the album, unfortunately, doesn't do half as much with sounds and styles that are already overplayed elsewhere.

Okay, so there's quaint traditional Chinese string instrumentation on 'here comes the eastern wind;, an otherwise feeble R&B ballet; an aggressive child rap on the unbashed Linkin Park rip-off, 'Coward'; and carefully apportioned syncopated beats and a neat tap dance sample on 'Dejavu', another R&B/rap number.

But surely such slight innovation cannot be the work of a so-called genius, right ? I'm not saying the has to reinvent the wheel every time he records a new album, but an AOR balled like 'A Fine Day' would definitely have been derided had it appeared on the latest Energy album.

Giving credit where credit is due, Ye Hui Mei is a good album; not something that would get him another Time magazine cover, if he indeed deserved the first.

Rating : 4.5 out of 5 stars

What song is Dejavu ? :?

petheads
08-22-2003, 05:24 PM
tap dancing would make "dejavu" 同一種調調 (tong yi zhong diao diao)? hmmm...very strange translation.

I can't stand how Singapore reviewers (another e.g. being ST reporter) give the album a pretty bad review and yet still give it 4.5 stars. huh? for fear of reporter bashing by fans for poor review? why can't they just state their own views!!!

How can an album that contains "sounds and styles that are already overplayed elsewhere" and a "feeble R&B ballet" and song that "would definitely have been derided had it appeared on the latest Energy album" be a "good album"?

this is total crap. :profanit:

rikastar
08-22-2003, 05:30 PM
Actually it's 3.5 stars out of 5.

He/She disses my fave male singer and fave group in one sentence... >.<

rachelle03
08-22-2003, 06:43 PM
He/She not only disses Jay in tat sentence but also ENERGY. Poor gal/guy, he/she just got hated by both groups of fans.

regina12
08-24-2003, 05:35 AM
Charlie Young just doesn't like Jay. He always gives Jay's albums terrible reviews and always says he's over-rated. Bah! I think Charlie doesn't have good music taste. He loves Canto pop to the core!

ker_ai_teresa
08-24-2003, 01:48 PM
music critics are quite technical in their opinions...it doesn't really mean anything to me coz i like the album :happy:

and i've seen worse reviews than this of other artists by s'porean critics. there was one who couldn't stop criticizing the amount of makeup elva had on for the cover pic of her album (don't know name). he/she didn't spend much time talking about the actual album....it was a bit silly really.

:cloud9: