Kelly Rowland or Beyonce Knowles

[squal87]

They both used to sing together in the group Destiny's Child, now they're doing their own solo careers. Kelly is hot with her single "Stole" while Beyonce is hot with her single "Crazy In Love".
In my opinion, Kelly is better because she is more talented and she has a better voice.
What do u guys think???

[xJayChoux]

Beyoncé. I think she has a better voice, and she's a beautiful woman. And yesterday I just bought her 'Dangerously in love' album :happy:. It's good, the songs are nice.

[getsu_04]

ooh,that's a tough choice.I have a bit more respect for Kelly though.Now that Beyonce is w/Jay Z she thinks she's hard...in her new MV for "Crazy in Love",all she does is show off her butt.I have to admit though,I really like her songs.

[cutie-pie]

personally i like kelly more - i like her stlye and voice; she's just so down to earth whereas beyonce is also pretty, but like some other ppl mentioned, now that shes w/ jay Z her image has completely changed...hehe just a tad 2 bootylicious

[xiAoJie]

i like both of them the same as each other, i was trying to pick one but i just couldn't. both of them have great voices (i didn't realise till recently that they sound kinda the same) and they're both really beautiful women.

[Miss_gun]

Destiny's Child is one of my fave group!! Although there is no more D.C....but I still love them!
hmm...I think ...Kelly is better!! I like her voice!!
Actually...both of them are hot and sexy!
But I prefer Kelly!

[AsianHotgirl]

DC didn't break up, they are still together, it's just they all wanted to make solo albums, but they are still together. I've met them before, while they were on an autograph tour and I cried, lol, I used to love them so much, they are still good though! I like Beyonce better, she has a better voice and she is so beautiful, not that Kelly isn't! But overall Kelly does seem more like a down to earth girl than Beyonce, but I still like Beyonce better!

[babyxv]

i like beyonce better because her songs are catchier and she has a more powerful voice

[linny]

Vocally, I think Beyonce has a better voice... But I prefer Kelly over Beyonce. Her image is nicer and more down-to-earth (and I adore her short hair). I dunno, I don't listen to either of them a whole lot with the exception of their first debut singles.

Anyway, I still like Kelly better.

[Liliann]

i like both of dem'' equallii
but i just like kelly abit more den'' Beyonce
i love dat song Dilemma when Kelly sings wid Nelly
...so sweetz..:hugz:

[nueng]

I like both of them 'cos their song is so nice!
DJ plays song 'Crazy in love' by 'Beyonce' everyday almost every hour~ I think this song is like the more u listen, the more u like it.

about 'Kelly' I love the song 'Dilemma' that she feat. with Nelly. Love Nelly!! hehee^^

[nycxbait]

beyonce is a tool, she uses sexuality to its fullest extent and is disgusting she cant sing, she isnt even that hot, kelly rowlands real shes cool.. but the real winner here is christaina augliera shes dirty, hot and can sing haha

[m o n k e e]

beyonce is a tool, she uses sexuality to its fullest extent and is disgusting she cant sing, she isnt even that hot, kelly rowlands real shes cool.. but the real winner here is christaina augliera shes dirty, hot and can sing haha

beyonce cant sing? :laughing: dats jus absurd.. its like sayin michael jackson cant dance.. jus coz mayb u dun like her voice (which i cant see how u cant), doesnt mean she cant sing. of the 3 destiny's child, shes has definitely the best voice... ne1 whos seeen a destinys child concert noes dat wen she opens her mouth, shes untouchable... but kelly's no slouch either.

i havnt herd much of beyonces material yet, but kelly' stuff is pretti gud...
oh yeh.. and beyonce IS HOT!

[JianDan[Ai]]

beyonce is a tool, she uses sexuality to its fullest extent and is disgusting she cant sing, she isnt even that hot, kelly rowlands real shes cool.. but the real winner here is christaina augliera shes dirty, hot and can sing haha

beyonce cant sing? :laughing: dats jus absurd.. its like sayin michael jackson cant dance.. jus coz mayb u dun like her voice (which i cant see how u cant), doesnt mean she cant sing. of the 3 destiny's child, shes has definitely the best voice... ne1 whos seeen a destinys child concert noes dat wen she opens her mouth, shes untouchable... but kelly's no slouch either.

i havnt herd much of beyonces material yet, but kelly' stuff is pretti gud...
oh yeh.. and beyonce IS HOT!

i woudlnt say beyonce "IS HOT" but i definetly agree that she has real talent and a very good voice....and christina augilera...ehh...i dun think she is hot ....or that she can sing :dry:

[nycxbait]

i beg to differ lol... beyonce at heart is a tool, her father was the manager therfore gave her most of the main songs and the other 2 were choirs members. Beyonce is not hot lol... shes good looking at best and okay at worst which is very respectable, its probably best to say that everyone will ahve their favorite, im not a fan therefore have no right arguing im just saying i dotn really liek her. Anyways you crew "diao" it means cocky right? or i dotn even know hwo to put this , the male gentila if nto please correct me

[m o n k e e]

well if u luk closely at wat i said, i dint argue that fact that she isnt a tool (maybe she is? i dun relli care.. u seem 2 noe more bout dat dan me) i was arguing dat she cold sing... n dat she can.

im not a fan of hers no, n du i relli fink shes DAT hot? lolz i was jus exaggeratin a bit dere haha.. but shes good lookin no?
wat does ma crew got 2 do wid nefin?? diao means cool, or means dick, so if ur callin me a dik becoz of my comments, den wateva, like i relli care...

[zhy378]

oohhh, it seems like a chick(even though both males, hehe) fight goin on here, between m o n k e e and nycxbait.

okay, back to the subject, is kinda hard to decide, i mean both been acting before- kelly on The Hugleys show and now in a movie that's gonna come out. beyonce in austin power goldmember. Also the destiny's child did a disney cartoon theme song for The Proud family. both been rumored to have rumor boyfriend, like, kelly with nelly and beyonce knowles with jay z. however they say r friends, when there r pic of beyonce and jay z. but who cares. their singin r good, just cuz beyonce do most of the solo part of songs that she seem better. but i say kelly cuz i think she have more potenial.

[Loony Luong]

Well, i think kelly is more talented well, nvm both are! but i like crazy and stole too but 0.5 more points go to beyonce for having the f4 vanness bonus asian track! :wink2:

[shouling]

Beyonce! Beyonce! Beyonce!

she is 10 times better than kelly. why you ask?
cuz she has Talent. not to say Kelly is a talent-less barbie doll, but Beyonce is just better at the soslo thing.

Kelly's album seems to me like a big "Down beat" she doesnt have alot of good bouncy songs that make you dance.

i dunno just my thoughts.

[AsianHotgirl]

beyonce is a tool, she uses sexuality to its fullest extent and is disgusting she cant sing, she isnt even that hot, kelly rowlands real shes cool.. but the real winner here is christaina augliera shes dirty, hot and can sing haha
I totally disagree, I think Beyonce has an amazing voice! And she is very beautiful, my opinion! Christina is
dirty, I agree with that, a dirty slut, don't mind my language, just my thoughts on her, and yea she can sing, she's pretty sometimes, but in her most recent video with Lil' kim, she looks gross, and I hate the way she colors in her eyebrows, c'mon she's famous, she can get professional make up artists to do it for her, instead of her doing it herself! But one thing, yes Christina might have a great voice, but her music sux!

[shouling]

ok. i agree that Kelly is a little more EARTHY (compared to the "sexy" clothing style of Beyonce),but that doesnt make her a better singer.
besides, i have given up on arguing "sexuality to sell music" and how it is wrong. its not gonna go away....nor is complaining about it gonna get us anywhere. i think pp should just stop making a fuss about it. it has become a normal thing....let it go.

[quote=nycxbait]yes Christina might have a great voice, but her music sux!

took the words right out of my mouth. :bow:

[AsianHotgirl]

ok. i agree that Kelly is a little more EARTHY (compared to the "sexy" clothing style of Beyonce),but that doesnt make her a better singer.
besides, i have given up on arguing "sexuality to sell music" and how it is wrong. its not gonna go away....nor is complaining about it gonna get us anywhere. i think pp should just stop making a fuss about it. it has become a normal thing....let it go.

yes Christina might have a great voice, but her music sux!

took the words right out of my mouth. :bow:
Yea, I agree with you on the sexuality thing, all famous female stars do it now, it's a part of their image, whether they dress revealing or not, does not necessarily mean that they are a slut or nething! You can never judge the person until you know them! Like I remember one type I was in Driver's Ed class and I guess some girls were talking about DC or something and one girl said that she didn't like Beyonce because she's so stuck up, but I was thinking she isn't at all, when I met DC, they were real sweethearts, Kelly was the nicest, she reached out to hug me first, and Michelle just didn't look excited to see her fans! Also, watching documentaries on DC, Beyonce doesn't seem stuck up, she reminds me of myself, I think she's pretty cool!

You know it sux how artists with really good voices, their music is not very good, like Christina, Nic Tse, Jacky Cheung!

[aznboi08]

I believe that they are both good
you can't really choose between the two
it's like choosing between ice cream and chocolate candy
=P

[GuArDiAn AnGeL]

hmmm tough question......for me..i think i like kelly too.....her voice isn't as squeeky lol...beyonce is good too...but yea...now shes wid jay-z shes like showing off in her mv "craZ in love" for example..and kelly is more...talented too...^^

[nyemie]

hmm i like beyonce's voice but her slutty style is so off ..

i really dont like hiphop music so i kinda dont like kelly's style either .. but her r&b song "stole" has nice lyrics ... nice song.. nice voice..

[panda_shine]

I use to like Beyonce better but after she did her solo thing I think i like Kelly Rowland better. But I still like them as Destiny's Child~

[Hyde]

Beyonce!
She and JayZ matches so well. And she DOES have more talent. She produced like, half of Survivor album and why do u think they let her sing almost every thing in the songs huh? lol
but i like em all.
Gosh ppl. don't forget michelle. she has an album out too and it's so underatted. she's way more down to earth than kelly. and her voice is special.

[AsianHotgirl]

I don't like Michelle's voice, but I agree that she is more down to earth than Kelly and Beyonce!

[Viv]

i think i lyk beyonce better but maybe its cuz shes more popular and im not that familiar with kelly rowland...but shes gettin into acting now...hehe freddy vs. jason...horror flick...somethin so unpredictable wen it comes to R&B stars to act in horror flix...

[SW33T_S3NSAT10N_D3S1R3]

oohhhh, this one's a toughie, but in the end I choose Beyonce Knowles, cause I realli like her songs, n she's really pretty. I like her new song the one feat. Jay Z!!! They have a relationship together, I think it's cute, but other ppl think that Beyonce is too hot 4 Jay Z. Anyways, I haven't realli heard any new songs from Kelly Rowland yet. N ya know what Beyonce was the 2 out of a hundred 4 the most irresistible women!! That isn't y I like her though, it mostly cause of her music!!!!!!!!!!

[en_en]

umm...i like kellys hair, and personality, but beyonces voice is really good, so i dunno. im not crazy about either of them, so i guess it doesnt really matter to me. i think i respect kelly more though, cause she always seem to be in the shadow of beyonce and my respect for beyonce kinda went down after i saw her solo album cover...is that suppose to be a shirt? its just strings with diamonds hanging from it. >_<

[Mashi Maro]

I personally like Kelly's voice more better. I don't like the feeling Beyonce gives when she sings. Kelly is a more vocal type e.g. Dilemma w/ Nelly and Beyonce is more intense and less vocal e.g. Crazy in Love.

[milkified]

i like kelly more...mayb the type of songs that she sings....i really like stole....n beyonce is kinda hot n hard...those really show off....but her songs r real nice.......

[swoc77]

beyonce cuz she's got the body and the ghetto booty, which some ppl are interested in. has anyone seen the crazy in love mv? damn that can be classified as softcore porn for some kids.

[AsianHotgirl]

swoc77 do you like any of their music?

[Jess]

After hearing Beyonce's "Crazy in Love" song about 50 times within the 2 hours I sat down and watched the MTV Video Music Awards, I'm beginning to hate that song so much.

[ahmui]

very hard choice, but i think i like kelly a little more than beyonce. i mean sure beyonces songs are real catchy and stuff, but its just cause its way more upbeat and they play it in clubs a lot, but i perfer kelly's style a little more, its less hollywood and more "real". kelly just seems to stand out from the crowd. even when they were dc, i still liked kellys voice through it all even though it always seems like beyonce is like the lead/main singer. the person i feel really bad for is michelle! she seems to have vansihed since the solo cds of beyonce and kelly came out!

[T i C k L 3 d]

i like kelly better. i dunno. beyonce just hogs the attention. kelly has SUCH a nice voice; but beyonce always gets the lead.

[getsu_04]

My brother woke me up at 2AM last night to tell me that he met Kelly Rowland at this restaurant "Nobu" in LA.She was waiting behind him for her car singing Justin Timberlake's "Rock your Body".He started joking around w/her and her friend,then he realized who she was but it was too late b/c the valet drove up w/her car.He's so lucky!The only famous person I ever met was Masaharu Morimoto from "Iron Chef",hehe.

[dancinwawa]

hmm....both are as good....their music was great yeaa... ^^
heee.....so kewl... :happy:

[lladee]

kelly! i think her voice is..stronger. only heard a few songs of beyonce's and won't rank them fantastic or what. okay maybe i'm a little biased down here...choosing someone with the same name as me...hehhh.

[gr8t_gal]

Is tricky. :?
Coz' i find that both their voices are talented and also similar. I couldn't tell who was singing which part (when they were both still in DChild).
I still think they both have similar way of singing and voice.
Only the tone is that Beyonce can sing louder and higher?
*shrugs* I like Kelly better only coz' her songs are more slow & has nice beats at same time, while Beyonce's new songs have more to do with R&B and less harmony-beat (you can't beat 'Dilemma' by Nelly and Kelly :wink2: Now that's classic R&B beat! :yeah: )